Marcelino's, New Windsor NY

I do not live here but I wish I did after visiting here. The locals were at the bar having a great time and it was the best pizza I've ever had.

Great pizza, great service and if you're getting a dinner there, try the shrimp francaise

Great food, great service, great taste in music, what more could you ask for? From out of town and would definitely stop back in again, thank you!

Great pizza slices. It's well proportioned and I particularly liked the dough taste. Owner was very kind and if you are a root beer fan they have a really tasty and high quality ingredient ones there.

Portions were generous. The Alfredo sauce was ok not out of this world. Staff were friendly.

Not stellar but not bad. Solid, local Italian food. I was surprised when I picked up the order to see they have a full bar! I will say the meatballs on the pasta were good. The small caesar salad was uninspired. The pizza was just as you might find it at half a dozen local pizza places: average to good, sauce was decent. The staff were very friendly, polite, and honored my mobile device coupon. You won't be overwhelmed, nor will you be disappointed.

We order from them about once a week, and the food is consistent and very good. I also used them for catering a small event recently.

Ordered a 22inch Calabria pizza, when I picked it up the gentleman behind the counter told me he read the ticket wrong made the wrong size pizza. Not a problem it was a big pizza so the smaller one worked. Drove 10 miles home and noticed the pizza was missing the eggplant Looks like instead of eggplant they gave me fresh tomatoes. Not sure I will try them again too many mistakes Should have been a simple order!

Consistently, week after week, every friday night, the best pizza around, love the variety of topping and specialty pies, the personal size pizza is not only perfectly priced
but also perfectly delicious.cant say enough good about this place, thank you rich for being here

Ordered a large pizza. The pizza tastes like it had been sitting and was reheated. The bottom of the pizza was burned and black. Waste of money. Pizza looks nothing like their advertising pizza. If I could give zero stars I would have.