Mary's Pizza and Pasta, Farmingdale NY

Mary's food is delicious and their portions large. I enjoyed my leftovers just as much the following day.ate it cold right out of the container and still so good!

Always great food and very friendly staff. Having been coming here for years! Best food in town

The food is delicious, but my order is NEVER correct. This time when my order was incorrect I called and let them know I ordered the eggplant rollatini pizza, I received a spinach and artichoke pizza with non-breaded eggplant. The employee told me that they never bread eggplant for an eggplant rollatini pizza - what Italian restaurant does not bread eggplant for eggplant rollatini? Do you know what un-breaded eggplant on a pizza looks like? Yup you guessed it - POOP. Not to mention, I had ordered this pizza in the past, and it was breaded. I LOVE your food Mary's, I really do, however the inconsistency of the food/ingredients is really concerning and I have no other way to get this info to you the right hands except the internet. I have ordered faithfully through the whole pandemic wrong or not, I will continue to order, I just hope this gets to the right person to create a change for the better.

Nice amount of acidity to the sauce, tasty cheese, on a base of fresh made crust. Keep up the good work, crew.

Tried to call to place an order. Was put on hold not even a “hello”. I get you’re busy but at least recognize my presence first!

Called back. Was hung up on a second time. Spoke to a manager a third time (at that point I was frustrated and angry) who didn’t care.

Never going back.

I do not live over here but currently house/dog sitting. I had a to send food out to an Italian family who had a passing in their family. After reading reviews online, I knew I had to choose this location.
I dealt with a gentleman last night on the phone who was so easy to work with and very attentive to my order. He was professional and had a friendly/welcoming voice on the phone.
Today, I requested an early delivery and you guys met it! You even came earlier and your delivery guy, was a sweetheart. Very nice even with a mask covering his face I knew he actually cared about delivering my big order hot & safe.

Thank you again for making this easy and delivering amazing food on time.
I will be telling co-workers /friends out here to use you guys.

Keep it up and stay safe

Mary's pizza and pasta in farmingdale mmmmm we just had the shark spec for shark week and wow! You've got some new customers! We were sure to get the garlic knots which are now my favorite knots out there! Thanks! 94.3.perfect!
We'll be back often!

Some of the best pizza on Long Island, thought their lunch special was overpriced at first but when I got my pizza I was pleasantly surprized. Grandma slices are huge and delicious, can't wait to come back.

Absolutely Ridiculous will never order from this place again. Ordered a chicken salad and a kids pasta and it came to $26.32. They don’t tell you they charge you for a delivery charge and the delivery guy was nasty and very rude. There online prices are NOT the same! You will be charged MORE! Very disappointed overall.

Hands down the best pizzeria in Farmingdale. Would definitely recommend. Service is excellent as well as the food. Never had a bad experience.

Got to hit them up with the 5 stars, been at this location a long while and exspandid to take over another section of building food good prices reasonable, staff is friendly and they get your food out rather quickly all good here.

First let me tell you the bread is on another level! Its freaking amazing! The penne alla vodka and all of the food we got was delicious!

The food here is always outstanding, the portions are more than generous and the staff is always extremely friendly.

Reasonably priced, great sauce, pasta cooked properly; a little too heavy on melted cheese in their dishes.

NEVER HAD A BAD EXPERIENCE. STAFF & OWNER WERE ALWAYS WELCOMING. BEEN GOING SINCE I MOVED HERE & WILL GO OUT OF MY WAY FOR THE LEVEL OF TASTE, QUALITY, & SERVICE I EXPECT.

Great place. We always come early to miss the crowd. Bread is delish, food is great, soda tastes how it should. Always happy.

Everything about this place is awesome. Big portions, plenty of options, and the food is delicious.

Food is great. And there's always parking. However, if you need to order delivery, DON'T! You will be waiting a really long time.

OMG! FLY IN MY SALAD! Nearly gaged and threw up. They don’t even deserve one star. Horrible experience do not order from here!

Their food is good. I will give them that. My issues are the screw "UP's", when you call in an order. 6 months ago my husband and I ordered a family calzone and a loaded pie. The calzone was RAW. We called they were very helpful and acommidating. So We ordered again since multiple times no major issues. Well tonight when we ordered we received the wrong order again. OK it happens 6 months not bad. My problem is that, yes as a customer you always ask would u like the wrong order back. As to show good faith and no scam to the business. However most say no and why? NYS FOOD REGULATIONS. Yes u BRING it back to show them however and not to be greedy and try to get a free meal. When the business takes the wrong pie back from you n just brings it in the back to the kitchen? That leaves a SOUR TASTE in my mouth. This food left and went into someone's home. You do not know what is in anyone's home. If you want the purchase back I understand however, what are you going to do with it. Sell it as special slicles, or a new order to someone? You made us a new pie our original order. Which we are thankful for. I'm just not sure I feel comfortable ordering anything other than special orders. Who knows could be someone's wrong order pawned off on u.