Milk Bar, New York NY

Compact location, no area for dine in. Awesome cake truffles, prices are decent. I will come back for sure.

This location continues to disappoint me. In April, I got a cake for my BBF's birthday & was told to come back later. When I did go back to pick it up, it looked like my 3 yr old niece wrote on it. I was truly embarrassed to present it to my friend at her bday dinner. I decided to give them another chance for my bday & both times I went today there was a "be right back sign" how many times can you post that sign a day!? I did finally get my cake after the 3rd time checking in & again the writing is not that great. Will not be returning to this location.

Stumbled upon this location as my wife and I were taking a catacombs tour around the corner. Tried their famous milk bar pie and choc chip cookie. Very sweet! But better than expected

The Milk bar pie was so delicious! It was perfect to walk the neighborhood and wish to have more.

This place is INCREDIBLE. We got the “Greatest Hits” bundle and every dessert was amazing in its own way. Hard recommend

Not nearly as good quality as it used to be. Paid $11 for a very small shake (maybe 8oz) that was half made up of a giant scoop of cornflakes, making it impossible to drink with the straw provided even when melted. Will not give them my business again.

I like the soft serve and love the option to customize the toppings accordingly to liking. There is no place to sit and enjoy, take out only.

Just happened to walk by this location on a beautiful day and had to finally try, as been wanting to stop by one forever. The cereal milk soft serve was the perfect treat for the heat, def get the corn flakes added to it for the crunch kind of salty savoriness is everything glad convinced me too. Spendy but worthy splurge

We got 2 milk cereals and they were both too salty, I don’t know if they are supposed to be so salty but ours were very disappointing.

I tried the famous milk cereal soft serve. Let me say it was salty AF. It tasted like they mistaken the sugar in the ice cream for salt. Definitely not what I expected

The young lady working tonight was sooo sweet and helpful! I came with my kids to try out some stuff (settled on cake slices, cookies and milk shake) and she was very informative and helpful. Told us about the products and was enthusiastic and delightful!
Would absolutely recommend others to come by! Thank you again:)

It seems to me that it is overrated. They gave us the cake from the refrigerator and it was frozen, we had to wait to eat it. It's a lot of sugar and butter but zero original flavor. Milk ice cream with cookies is very heavy. A disappointment.but I guess that's the flavor they like here.

Soft serve ice cream was too sweet for me. Price of a small cup is $9.50 with tax, which is outrageous. Customer service was great. Take out only. Street parking only.

I was really excited to try this ice cream and cake but it wasn't very good at all. It was too sugary and not very flavorful. It wasn't good honestly, super disappointed

Definitely a tasty confetti cake, but $11 for a tiny slice? $11 seems a bit excessive, unless we are getting a good sized slice and it is the best confetti cake on earth. It is good, but it is definitely not the best in my humble opinion.

I've been dreaming of coming here FOREVER and I finally made it happen! Even though it's freezing outside (-12C), I braved the cold to try their famous cereal milk soft serve and let me tell you, it was worth it! SO GOOD. I don't think I can get enough, so I'll definitely be back. And to top it off, I also got their famous pie and it was 100/10 amazing.