Nautilus Diner, Mamaroneck NY

Everything fine. The service was a little moody. Otherwise everything is fine. We'll definitely go back.

Giving this three stars because we went to the diner just to eat. It took them forever to take our order, bring our food and check. It was empty.maybe three other tables. We waited over 40 minutes for our food. Food is mediocre but I don't think I'd come back.

My grandparents love this place. We have been eating there since I was a little girl. Because they eat there almost every Sunday the staff is very friendly with them. That is nice and heartwarming, but it doesn't make up for the lackluster food for me. There have been several times when I've wanted to send back food but wouldn't simply to appease my grands. I abhor paying for subpar food though. And frankly this food hasn't been stellar in at least a decade. They push through volume but not necessarily quality. Which is a shame because nothing beats good diner food. This just isn't it. Don't get me wrong. There are certain menu items that are yummy and if they are less busy usually the food is of higher caliber. But there are other diners in the area that are more consistent and have better food.

My Friends brought me here after my Birthday Party to top off the celebration with this Pumkin Spice Cheesecake. The Atmosphere, Food, and Service at the Nautilus is always top tier.but the way I think about this Cheesecake all year long. 10 out of 10 would highly recommend!

It was ok bit overpriced. Ordered 1 Omelet with ham and cheese. Ordered another with just cheese bcuz i wanted it with bacon but not on the menu. I ask if I they can add bacon to the 2nd omelet waiter said sure no problem. Food comes and the home fries were undercooked imo. The 2nd omelet came with the bacon but also with ham. I asked for just cheese+bacon on the 2nd the omelet. The waiter never came around to ask us"is everything ok "or would we "like anything else" like most diners do. I usually tip around $20 but I only tipped $4 bcuz service was bad. I received undercooked home fries and the wrong omelet.

This has been my go to diner for years. There are many options and the food is good as is the service. The atmosphere depends on where you are seated.

Solid local diner. Nothing spectacular, but really good omelettes and solid breakfast foods. Decent salads. GREAT service - the team keeps us coming back.

There breakfast/lunch and dinner is amazing large menu options, The waitress I usually wait for is Veronica she's always on point although all staff are friendly.

We've never had a bad meal here. You probably won't find a better diner that serves French Toast as good as they do in this part of Westchester. I've driven past many diners to get here.

Great customers service food was awesome I hope to visit again! My kids enjoyed the banana pancakes and the fruit Belgian waffles I would recommend while my friend loved the sausage egg and cheese sandwich

Food was good. The waitress appeared distracted by other customers. Took a while to get our orders. She also gave us the wrong check.

We were a group of five one evening and we had an absolutely delicious meal. The service was excellent and the place is very clean. I had a cop salad that was chopped up to perfection and served with croutons. Other great dishes that night were an egg white spinach omelet, a western omelette, brisket sandwich, and chicken fingers. The french fries were cooked to perfection. For dessert we shared a piece of seven layer cake which was out of this world with a couple of cups of coffee and a nice tea. For a diner, this was superb I would highly recommend it. It was our first time here and we loved it.

Great place to go for a meal. Visit it once a week
Very good food.
Management very attentive and friendly.
Family atmosphere.

Step back in time to the Nautilus Diner. Built less than 40 years ago, it has that old world charm. Portions are big, and the Pastrami is fantastic. Run, don't walk to the Nautilus, do it and do it now!

Disappointed ordered a hungry man 2 eggs 2 sausage 3 pancakes 18.99 home fries additional 6.50 and toast 2 slices 2.00 total of 27.00 very overpriced