Paulie's Tackle, Montauk NY

Can’t say enough good about Paulie and co. - these guys won’t steer you wrong or try to oversell you, and if you ask for tips on fishing the area they’re always happy to give some pointers. Best prices around for hooks and sinkers too! Stop by and see them when you’re creeping the beaches for that prize striper!

Horrible experience. Cursed us out multiple times even though we spent over 200 dollars. Would’ve preferred to give my money to a more deserving business

I just returned from a trip up the coast from Pa to Maine & one of the best parts of the trip was fishing Montauk & meeting Paulie. Paulie was very helpful & what a personality. Never change. Maybe I will return to fish Montauk someday again. Thanks for everything.

Very helpful to a complete novice and a young kid who wanted to learn about fishing. Paulie was super friendly and took his time to explain everything and was super patient explaining the complete basics to a novice. Recommended.