Pizza Boys, New York Mills NY

Stopped in late in the evening sunday before closing. Even tho it was late, the staff was kind and some of the friendliest people I've had at a pizza place, their Sicilian upside down pizza and chicken wings pizza slices were amazing, they warmed them up and probably some of the best pizza I've had in quite a while. My friend got a drink from the bar and said it was properly made and tasted great. Overall a great & quite evening at pizza boys and can't wait to eat there again

Being from Connecticut I am very picky about my pizza, but this was definitely the best pizza I’ve ever had in upstate New York. Awesome staff at the counter and bar. Totally coming back next time I am up this way. Thank you guys again!

Wow. Finally tried chicken riggies while in Utica for a couple of days. Phenomenal. And the inside out/upside down whatever pizza is amazing! Great slices too.

I waited 45 minutes for a sub with 4 things on it and most people were standing around waiting to be waited on not impressed

Not sure what happened, but it took the server 4 trips before she had the right dressing for my salad. We also ordered sit in and got take out. The food was very good, but the service was not.

I ordered 2 large pizzas and 10 wings for an office lunch meeting at The Hartford building on 4/27. The meeting started at 12: 30 pm. I made the call at 11: 51am. The bill came to $64 and change. (A bit high-priced compared to other places in my experience). I chose Pizza Boys from maps because they had the highest rating (4.2*) within a 3 mile distance. The lady on the phone stated that the delivery time would be 45 min to an hour. This would put arrival at between 12: 40 and 12: 55pm. In my opinion, that is much too long to deliver 2 pizzas and 10 wings from less than 5 miles away, but I felt like I had called early enough to accept the terms. At 1: 05pm I called for an update, and she stated that the driver was on his way. At 1: 15pm I called again, and she stated that he had just left (clearly a mistake). At 1: 20pm, he showed up with the food which, as far as taste experience was fair.

At $64 I would rather not have to wait a minimum of 20 extra minutes for mediocre food while apologizing to a meeting room full of people because lunch hadn't arrived yet.

Everything they serve is swimming in grease and their "garlic bread" is literally garlic toast. It's not expensive but you'd think that lack of quality would knock the price down some seeing as though competitors with comparable pricing can manage to serve something actually palatable.

Great pizza! I get it for lunch when I feel like a slice, they have deep dish and regular new york style. Sauce is good! They've opened up the back and there is now a tap room/bar

Ordered through Door Dash, it was a busy night so the food wasn't warm. Normally I be frustrated, but the pizza and wings were amazing! Classic in both cases! Must try.

Sunday evening at 6.30pm and we had our choice of seating - table or bar. Loaded cheese fries were delicious. Burgers were delicious. Bartender was very friendly and attentive. A very extensive beer lost as well.

Had a medium pizza and the boom boom chicken salad! It's my favorite there! One salad is enough to feed 2 with leftovers! Beer tender was great!

Stopped in for a quick slice and was out the door within minutes. Staff is attentive and prices are fair.

They have a large bar/dining area on the other end of the shop that looks like a great place to meet and watch a game or catch up with friends. Coming from long island, Pizza boy's pizza comes close to what I'm accustomed to, highly recommended.

Pizza Is really crispy and the so called Large Antipasto sucks it's too small and it smelled like vegetables that were getting old and the lettuce is not real lettuce

This was the worst food I have had in a long time bread was not even cooked all the way and chicken Alfredo with broccoli was gross and I couldn’t even eat it very disappointed spent almost 26 dollars for nasty food

Best pizza in 20 miles. It’s always consistent and their wings are always good. They have great subs and sandwiches and their garlic knots are always buttery. If you’re looking for a good bar, the other side of the house does that well

Ordering Ease - A
Price - C-
Price Transparency - D
Delivery Communication Systems - B
Actual Delivery - D

Food Temperature - D
Food Quality - C+
Chance I will order again - 0%

Tiny wings. Sauceless Pizza. If your door dashing or grub hubbing, please get something closer, if not spend the extra dollar on something further. Never ordering here again.

Used to love this place but it's not the same anymore. Take heed from all the people reiterating the same sentiments. Staff needs training on how to properly take orders and I've come to realize after reading some other reviews that they treat a costumer as an inconvenience. After receiving the wrong pizza (I ordered and confirmed that I wanted crispy chicken gold dust pizza) I called back to inform them of the situation and was asked if they could just credit my account 10 dollars when I told them I still needed to eat and wanted the pizza I ordered. Cue the curtness from merely wanting what I paid for. But at least they were gonna bring me a pizza so I could eat. When I did get my replacement it was soggy and doe was not even cooked through. Do yourself a favor please don't be treated like an inconvenience and then given less than acceptable customer service go to Big Jay's or Venice or cappos or even Tony's they won't leave a bad taste in your mouth

I call and place a order at 6: 30pm they said when the food is ready they will send it
I call at 8: 40 just to check up and they said there just putting the pizza in
And I've been waiting and got nothing it's 11: 07 and got no food, I'm very hungry and very upset

I've only grabbed slices from here to go but man are they delicious. One of my favorite pizzerias in the area. HUGE fan of their "Grandma". I always stop when I'm in there area. It's very nice inside and gives off a great atmosphere. Highly recommend. Will update if I ever sit to eat.