Pizza Pete's, New York NY

Pretty standard NYC slice shop, nice for a quick emergency slice. Nothing different or outstanding but the employees were nice and helpful. Quick to heat and serve the slices.

Great pizza, normal pizza place from the old school, tile, pizza ovens, nothing extraneous, nothing weird. If you want a slice of pizza go here, right now, it's good and unassuming.

Good pizza made with quality Grande ingredients not your cheap $ 1 pizza.
Its a bit of dive owners are not present but guys work hard. Also pro it has a bathroom!

Pizza Pete’s was recommended to us from a family member who had visited previously.

It didn’t disappoint! Quality ingredients and great taste. This is the NYC Pizza slice we envisioned.

Ordererd take out.eta. 45-55mins
Called after 70mins: "It's out for delivery"
ok
2hrs after placing the order still nothing;
"Unfortunately we've cancelled order due to miscommunication"
I have no clue where the "miscommunication" happened.
Embaressing.

Pizza Pete's is SO good - I came across this place while walking the Upper West Side. This is the perfect spot to grab a quick slice + a Diet Coke to-go. The staff are friendly and the service is super fast, and the pizza (most importantly) is AMAZING. Highly recommend, I will be returning here!

The way they cook the pizza makes the crust nice and crispy on the bottom. The sauce is good. The cheese they use isn't the best. It's a blended cheese so it separates which leaves for not the best texture. Overall it was decent. I don't think it's a bad choice for pizza but it wouldn't be a place, as a visitor to the city, that I would come back to again and again.

Thé worst pizza I’ve ever had. I ordered twice at this place. First was four cheeses kind of pizza. Actually it was only 2 cheese pizza. Cheep American type cheese and cheep mozzarella kind of… just plastic rubbish. Second time I ordered pizza margarita. I regret I didn’t take a pic. There were some spots of dry tomato paste, just a paste. Not juicy sous, not, why to bother yourself to make some souse. My husband asked for Parmesan on top. “Parmesan” didn’t look like Parmesan nether tasted like one.
Rubbish ingredients won’t make delicious food. Love yourself don’t eat there

Gentlemen, whoever wants to eat a real Pizza, Crispy and soft to the Palate uyyyy here it is, but you can't imagine the flavor. There is santisssimo what a cutie. And it's not greasy.

A hidden gem, and probably the best pizza in Manhattan. I’ve been a customer for over a decade.

I ordered a pizza pie on slice app. After contacting slice after waiting over an hour I was told pizza was delivered. IT WAS NEVER DELIVERED. No refund. Straight up stole my money. Beware.

Chicago style pizza was huge and delicious. Pretty deep for NY, and the crust was perfectly done. Got two extra toppings and the pizza was loaded.

It was my 1st time coming to New York. Pete's was my 1st stop to try there pizza and the pizza definitely tasted better. I'm from Miami I would recommend to give them a try you won't be disappointed.

Solid pizza and a fair price. Their margherita is my fave in the city, and god knows I've eaten my share of pizza. Would recommend!

Pizza Pete’s is great! The normal pie is tasty, but where they really excel is the fresh mozzarella Sicilian pies. Sauce is a bit spicer and the cheese is really good. Also the prices and speed of delivery is really good. Don’t sleep on them!

Pizza is a true tasting NY pizza. Crust is edible, too. They have various types of pizza to suit your taste. So don't let the small place fool you. It's the whole in the wall establishments that are authentic.

WARNING! Ordered a pizza and over 2 hours later it still hasn’t arrived. Can’t risk them spitting in the pizza out of revenge if I complain, so canceled. AVOID AVOID AVOID