Best Pizza Restaurant New York: reviews, page 3

Best pizza store. Pizza is insane and rated very highly by famous pizza critics like Dave portnoy. Store is clean and service is amazing, but they...

Really awesome pizza. I had been so addicted to Joe and Sal's I only recently tried this place and loved everything I had. I ordered the soprasata and...

So it’s my first visit to New York and I stumbled into this small but cozy pizzeria. The food was great. Definitely a must try

Classic Italian restaurant. The food, the drinks, the people. This is the perfect old school Italian place. Bartenders are incredible.

The best service, the employees were so friendly and helpful! Will definitely return!

Sadly, it’s open ONLY FOR “TAKE OUT FOOD AND BUY GOODS”. Deserted at a moment due to COVID-19. They don’t know when they’ll fully reopen. So, when it says...

Brought my sister out to dinner. First they wouldn’t sit us in the actual restaurant they put the 3 of us in the stupid shanty outside. So right of the...

Ordered the Goodfellow signature pizza. I didn't realize they would be skimpy on the toppings. I didn't care for the mussels. It tasted...

I have given this place MORE than enough chances. Ill start with the very first one. Ate inside before pandemic, found a hair in my salad. I know...

Pasta and lasagna dishes were bland. Pizza was ok!
Nothing special, midiocre at best!

This place has been great every time I go there. I have gotten their paninis, heros, salads, and pizza. Prices are a bit high but very clear and worth...

Everything was perfect, great atmosphere and food was delicious. The service was good too.

Great stop for lunch today! I walked in, service was prompt and friendly. Pizza was ready and served within a minute or two. Crust had a slight crisp...

Favorite local spot for a delicious Italian meal, brick oven pizza and wine selection for an unbeatable price. Bono has been my first to go option...

Good restaurant, correct service. The food is good, but like almost every restaurant on the east coast: sugar everywhere. Especially the balsamic...

Always love the pizza, sandwiches hot and cold. Great family business

Anazingly flavorful and delicious puzza that is different than most others in the area and definately worth a taste. Just don't expect fancy dining...

Solid new york slice.the dough isn't the best which means the garlic knots are a bit dry and like crumbly but they are seasoned like over the top but...

The best Italian restaurant in New York City! I’ve been here a few times and picked this place for my company’s holiday party recently. Very very...

Stopped off for a bit before going to the airport. The staff was really friendly. My wife told me we will be coming back. She loved the atmosphere