Pizza Time, Mastic Beach NY

George has been giving his customers top-notch food for years! If you need a catering done or just want to stop in for a slice, you will not be disappointed!

Me and my wife had a pleasant experience dining in at Pizza Time the food is great the staff is great the price is great the customers are great

I moved out here from Queens and believe me. I worked in all 5 Boro's. I know great Italian cuisine. From "Carmine's" on the upper west side to "King Umberto's" of Fongoul square (Elmont). Since I tasted Pizza Time this place has been my "go to". The pizza is great! The superbowl buffalo wings were out of control! If you have not had the Veal Cutlet Parmesan on a garlic bread Hero!? Then you don't know what you are missing! Not only "delish" but the Veal is so tender it melts in your mouth. I really force the second half down (already full from 1st half of hero) just cause it's that good! To everyone at Pizza Time, keep up the good work! YOU GUYS NEVER DISAPPOINT!


AL

Tonight hey seemed more interested in a soccer game than the customer sorry footbol didn't even get my food they where giving it to someone else and as I and the person they where trying to give the food to where telling them hey that's not mine and I'm telling the guy hey that's mine in Spanish his language he still proceeds to ignore me and give my food to someone else after waiting 20 mins for 2 slices of BBQ I just walked out

Absolutely terrible. Tried 2 specialty pizzas and ended up throwing them out. How can pizza be this lousy on LI, it's embarrassing.

Quaint pizza shop with a nice selection of pizza and pasta dishes. Service is always on point.

I love their zeppoles with the cannoli cream in the middle. Also the pepperoni wheel looking things with a side of sauce is so delicious omg.

George and his staff at pizza time are always polite food always good and fresh no matter what time is come

Place has ok food but putting someone on hold for 10 minutes while i could hear everything they were talking about the customers and taking in orders yes 3 orders a matter a fact so i hung up and called back and started to complain only to get attitude then hung up on. Super bad customer service and attitude. Will not be ordering from them anymore as Ninos pizza is way better and mamas is also better with the customer service you would expect. Horrible way to treat a customer for a run of the mill run down pizza place. Such a shame. Stay away from this place. Don't waste your time or money spend a little bit more and get way better pizza.

George and his staff are always polite. The food is excellent. I have ordered Heros, Neopolitan and Sicilian pizza, and the specials. The best is the Chicken Dinner for $11.95. That runs everyday from 11 AM until 4 PM. Don't forget to ask about the other specials. I highly recommend Pizza Time, you won't be disappointed.

Best pizza around. I call and they know my order by the sound of my voice. George and the staff are always so friendly and courteous. My little guy asks for pizza George to make dinner every night.

After a day at work I stop to get my daughter and her friend pizza I walk in here this girl was friendly took my order btw was 4 pieces pepperoni pizza she proceeds to put the pepperoni on the pizza WITHOUT GLOVES &with COVID &everything pls so I thought to myself ok well any germs will burn off in oven but then she Comes over and gets my money gives me back my change goes over and gets the pizza out the oven without gloves touches it cuts it without gloves the meantime she was scratching her face also and touching her hair! Will not be going back!

Great place, looks are indeed deceiving, at first I thought this is not a good place, but I do want to support the neighborhood business. Long story short, I was totally wrong.
This is my go to place for pizza.
The staff was not wearing masks that's why on l y 4 stars.

I have been to many pizza restaurants in my life. This one is the best one. I love how it tastes just like the good pizza you find in NYC, but it's local. There pizza is absolutely delicious. I want this to be the thing I eat the second before I die.

Food is great but George really needs to get rid of the old women who answer the phone she is so nasty makes you second guess if you are hungry the two young girls are awesome

The old man that use to own it was great. Jen /Jessica that owns it now is no good. Very rude individual. I will NEVER ORDER FROM HERE AGAIN! I SUGGEST YOU STAY AWAY FROM HERE! Use to be our favorite spot I would rather order pizza hut.