Rogues Harbor Inn 1830 LLC, Lansing NY

Our room was cozy and beautifully furnished. Our hosts were friendly and accommodating. We loved that there was a restaurant attached to the inn. We were able to eat, have a couple drinks, and walk back to our room. Such a plus for us! Both business were well staffed and hospitable. Would highly recommend this establishment!

It was a pleasure staying in this historic hotel. The room was clean and comfortable. We slept well and enjoyed a delicious breakfast before heading out. We’ll be back.

Clean, comfortable, historic inn. Was a former Stagecoach Tavern, a speak easy and part of the Underground Railroad.
Delicious homemade breakfast served daily.
Staff was extremely friendly and accommodating helping us locate the best wineries and waterfalls for hiking. Would definitely return.
Thanks Eileen and Max

The staff was very friendly and amenable. Breakfast at the inn was great and they accommodated our vegan diets.
The room was very clean and cute. Definitely would stay here again!

My wife and I had a wonderful stay at Rogues Harbor Inn. Our host, Eileen, went out of her way to make a terrific breakfast that met my wife's specific diet. We would definitely recommend staying there.

A quaint place to spend sometime! Eileen was awesome in making sure that we had everything we needed. The hospitality from the entire staff was great, and the breakfast was delicious. The 24 hour coffee is also a spectacular touch! The room was clean and showers worked well. We really enjoyed the time we spent here and in the surrounding area.

Owner was extremely accommodating, works hard, & strives for perfection. Rooms were clean & comfortable. I appreciated the extra thought put into our stay like the noise cancellation machines in each room (it's an old building), the early check in accommodation, and nice gestures like self serve coffee, guest refrigerator, and home cooked meals. The front patio/garden area is not complete yet with updates, but we enjoyed exploring Ithaca during the day and being cozy in our rooms at night. We also had an adjoining room which was perfect for friend talks.

An average hotel to stay in Lansing near Ithaca. The room wasn’t very comfortable (bed and pillows) and the windows were sealed with a plastic screen so you can’t open any window and no proper ventilation in the room. The service was good and the staff were friendly. The breakfast was simple and good. The location is ok, 10 minutes away from Ithaca.

My girlfriend and I stayed at Rogues Harbor Inn for 3 nights. We absolutely adored our stay, and hope to return. The staff was quite accommodating and the desk attendant, Max, gave us some wonderful recommendations. In addition, breakfast was an entire event where we dined in the ballroom, while very kind servers waited on us, providing home cooked meals.

Pretty historic inn. Very musty in the entire place, so be sure you can deal with that before you book. The staff and owner are very friendly and accommodating!

Very comfortable rooms, friendly & helpful staff, charming & historic building; breakfast served in a beautiful ballroom! Convenient to city and many other sites. Would definitely stay again.

I have to give props to owner only. She was very nice and accomadating to our early arrival. That's all though. This is NOT HANDICAP FRIENDLY. You will have to do a number of steep steps. To room up 2 flights. To eat up 4 sets. Bed was like a board gone rouge. Took showers and literally burned skin. Boiler I assume? Room was very drafty and cold. Steam heat was not enough. Toliet ran all night I thought it was the falls. We got zero sleep as you can hear every truck car motor cycle on the main road 34b. You can also hear everyone in the halls talking all night or walking to bathroom. Food. Hmm. We went up to see about getting coffee at 7.30 am. No-one around. Opened kitchen door and were shocked at mess. Needless to say we did not stay for breakfast. We left as soon as we could and slept at home all day. Decor far from historical, more like cheap garage sale. To bad could be nice if you had lots of money. Ps. They are doing construction. So lots of nails and screws in parking lot.

Beautiful historic hotel - tastefully decorated! Eileen and her staff are extremely helpful and always had a local attraction to reccomend with directions on how to get to them. Breakfast was served daily in a grand room and it was very tasty and hearty. Thanks for the wonderful stay!

Was a bad experience. The room #7 was not clean. There were PUBIC hairs in the bed from last Tennant. Large cobbwebs in bathroom. Had to contact the night caretaker to change sheets. Contacted Dana and Suzanne, all they said is that room was clean, they live in Jersey according to Amanda who changed our sheets. Also Amanda apologizeed for the sorry sheets because she was busy and the owners think we are making this up. This was our first experience with an Airbnb and might be last especially with the way the owners reacted. I have never left a bad review- until now. Food was cold in the morning. Would not recommend at all.

I love this history rich beautiful place. It is absolutely gorgeous and not far from Ithaca or Cayuga Lake. The menu has been so creative, inclusive, delicious and with so much variety. Sad we can’t go here this Mother’s Day but looking forward to whoever buys it keeping it an awesome place to dine and stay. Thanks Rogue’s Harbor! You are awesome.

Very fun historic building. Restaurant is currently closed as the property is in the process of being sold. Still renting rooms through Airbnb.

Went for trivia, nice place with plenty of regulars. Bartender walked over to our table a few times to refill. Good service

Very clean and beautiful rooms. The Food is great! Every time i left my room i noticed a different historic picture. I look forward to returning.

Good food, and the porch is a really nice place to sit on a warm day. The wings are particularly good, but you'll need to ask for plenty of napkins.

Good food in Commencement weekend in Ithaca. We had a larger group, and the inn accommodated us well for dinner. Great local feel.