Roma Ristorante & Pizzeria, Sidney NY

Spent $148.00 for take out of pizza and some dinners. Chicken parm burnt. How do you plate and serve this to people?

Once you get past the parking lot and the building exterior you are in for a treat. My bride and I have.been very pleased with all the food we have enjoyed.

We have had variety of options from the menu. From pizza to Seafood Antipasto. Everything was great! My only negative is that I don't like the Italian sausage on their pizza. I prefer chunks of sausage.

My bride loves the Saturday prime rib and we both enjoy the live music.

This place does not have a good Yelp review, so we did not expect much. Dana welcomed us and made everything possible. We started with two appetizers; they were good. Dana checked on us periodically. We wanted the pasta with Fra Diavolo sauce and the chef, a lady, made it for us. Awesome sauce. The service was excellent and prompt. The portions were huge, but we made room for dessert. You can’t go wrong with Cannoli. We would go back.

Excellent weekly specials very good pasta a good Italian place to eat very good service very attentive waitresses reasonably priced

I like to be honest with my reviews and i wasn't expecting much but the food was amazing and quality. Dinner rolls were so good! I will be back on my next visit up here!

Food and service were good. We had the Mediterranean seafood medley. Fried haddock, scallops and calamari. Waitress was very good. Not sure their AC was working to good cuz it got pretty warm in there.

Last week I ordered the hot wings from here. Before doing so I asked if they could be done dairy free, since I dietary sensitivity to it. The person on the phone was helpful and checked for me. The wings were ready to pick up at the specified time. They were nicely crispy, with a well rounded flavor, and actually had a proper amount of heat to them. Would get again.

18$ for shrimp alfredo that’s mediocre at best. The real kicker is that there were no shrimp. 4$ to add absolutely nothing to my meal. My pizza and garlic knots were warm at best. I guess there was a better attempt with them. But I don’t think I’ll be ordering from here again for quite a while.

Great chicken Posen huge portions i had to bring 2/3 home for tomorrow cause I was stuffed

3rd strike. No more.
We’ve been eating here since they opened and have been pleased.

Last 3 takeouts were terrible.

1st takeout the sauce tasted like a cheep sweet canned sauce.

2nd takeout we received no meatballs with our spaghetti and meatball dinner. But the sauce was better. Not like it used to be though.

3rd and final was yesterdays takeout spaghetti and meatball dinner. We got the meatballs. But nearly no sauce. The angle hair pasta had a pink tinge and the only sauce was on the meatballs.

So unfortunately after all these years, Roma’s in Sidney is off our list for food.

The food is consistently good here. I generally don’t eat Italian out because I make it at home. I love eggplant but don’t enjoy cooking it. So it is my go to when I eat at an Italian restaurant. This one didn’t disappoint.

So delicious and recommended to share pasta plate with friend and spouse becuase get full. Yum!

Absolutely loved it did get in a little late so we only got live music for half of our dinner.

Everything was good. But my husband was disappointed in his "lasagna" it was just meatballs and sauce and cheese no noodles.

Just awful… after years of Roma’s being our first choice, after tonight never again! I get that the pandemic has been tough, inflation is hitting food service businesses hard, etc.

Ordered two dozen wings tonight to be picked up and brought home. WINGS! In upstate NY! Yes they’re expensive ($14 a dozen) due to low supply/high demand… still, sometimes you have a hankering. We were never told they would be ‘boneless’ when placing or picking up the order - never even given an option. Get home and the containers were full of Tyson chicken nuggets (the ones they ship to China to be ‘processed’, breaded & packaged to be shipped back to your grocer’s/dollar store’s freezer). Absolutely disgusting. We called back to report the error. “That’s all we serve now, and has been for some time. ” If you want to ‘package’ a kids meal as an appetizer, go for it. But be honest. If I wanted McNuggets, there’s a drive-thru right up the street for half the price!

Even worse, I still had to cook dinner because we ordered the wings as a gluten-free option for a family member that couldn’t ‘enjoy’ the rubber-crusted pizza we received. Gross. And so sad! I am second to none as a booster for local business, but I won’t be dining out or ordering Italian in Sidney anymore. Get it together, Roma’s, or you’ll lose the rest of your loyal customers. Yuck!

Mostly go to Sals but he waa closed on Sundays. We thought we'd try here. Worst mistake ever. The waitress didnt give us a menu we had to ask. Finally came to get our order and we had to even ask when we getting our drinks. Food prices were expensive but quality was nasty. Stromboli was burnt, scant of meat and dripping oil, sent back and that one was even worse. Whole plate had oil on it from trying to eat it. Pizza was bland. Spaghetti was nasty. Meatballs were small and looked like they been boiled. Hardly any sauce and what was didn't even stick to the pasta. They gave you a hard roll for the spaghetti and that was hard and cold. I was so upset. I told them to cancel my order as they were going to make another pasta for me. You get charged if you want marinara sauce which should be included for your stromboli. Very disappointed. Will not ever go again.

It's a little dark inside, but clean and friendly. The food is good and the portions are large.

Understandably not a busy day, Dec. 26th.but this is not great. Pull in, parking lot is dark and empty. Big sign is half lit. No neon signs are on, including the open sign. Interior lights are on so I called to confirm they're open. Inside is quiet with a couple things ready to go, but no slices. I try to use the soda fountain an there's no ice. Flavor shots don't work. Then there's no straws to be found. I had to ask for one. It's dead in there and yet the place is a wreck. What are they doing? And the pepperoni roll had very little pepperoni. Really a mozzarella roll!