Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, Newark NY

Ordering was ok. We were greeted timely upon walking in. Our salads were special orders due to dislike with some of the topping choices. My ceasar salad came out and it was just an over priced garden salad. When we went to the counter to question the salad we were told that it was their ceaser salad and she wasn't sure why they call it that. None of the toppings were what was supposed to be on it. If it wasn't for a gift card we had I would not have eaten here.

Didn't understand how to take an order on the phone! Took about 10 mins, asked them to cook the chicken wings longer to be crispy, and they were like chewing on flesh! Told him 3 TIMES extra crispy! Pizza was doughy and not done and NO SAUCE! And way to expensive for chicken wings, and food that was not appetizing! Won't be going back anytime soon!

Show up at 12: 05 no available slice's wait 15 min to get a slice with hardly no sauce very dry.

I ordered mild and hot wings And both had no flavor at all. Also When I called to order the guy was very rude.

Very Disappointed, its been awhile since we have ordered from the Newark Salvatore's. Tried to call the store the next day since it was late when we ordered. Couldn't get anyone when we called.
Ordered Wings well done, they were far from well done, very rubbery, and under cooked. There was barely any sauce on the wings.
Garbage plate, the fries were like mush.
These are things we have ordered in the past and never had an issue.

I will never go here again it took 30 minutes for them to make a sub the bumbling guy behind the counter acted like he didn't know how to take an order and a young girl was playing with her hair behind the counter over the pizzas that you can get by the slice

Both times we ordered from this place we had issues. Either the food was made wrong or we got someone else’s order. Took almost 3 hours to get our correct food, only for it to show up and not be cooked properly. Disgusting. What a waste of $80. Definitely not ordering from here again. Nobody wants a raw rubber chicken sub

Fix your hours on the website. Says opened til 11 and allowed us to order at 10: 02 on a Saturday. The last time we ordered here, you were out of multiple things and we had to change our order. Two out of two annoying experiences here. Shame.

Update: Still awful here. The ready slice I was given was cold with hardened cheese. Went straight in the garbage. It was too close to closing for you to have fresh hot pizza as advertised, apparently. Disgusting. Should have known better. And what kind of pizza place closes at 8pm anyway? Will never give this place another chance. My bad

Worst place to order food from, waited two hours for our food and was made totally wrong. Save yourself the hassle order somewhere else.