Sea Island, Brooklyn NY
| Address | 611 Sutter Ave, Brooklyn, NY, United States | ||||||||||
| Phone | +1 347-627-7252 | ||||||||||
| Hours |
|
||||||||||
| Categories | Seafood Restaurant | ||||||||||
| Rating | 2.9 10 reviews | ||||||||||
|
Similar companies nearby Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen — 624 Conduit Blvd, Brooklyn, NY Lenny's Clam Bar — 161-03 Cross Bay Blvd, Howard Beach, NY El Anzuelo Fino — 98-01 Jamaica Ave, Queens, NY Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen — 682 B Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, NY |
Sea Island reviews
10I HAD TURKEY WING, MAC & CHEESE & COLLARD GREENS. THE TURKEY WINGS WERE UNDER COOKED COLLARD GREENS HAD NO SEASONING AND THE MAC & CHEESE COULDVE BEEN SEASONED AS WELL. OVERALL THE STAFF WAS NICE BUT I WILL NEVER EVER GO BACK THERE AGAIN. THE FOOD WAS HORRIBLE.
Out of an order of 4 items, the star of the show was the grilled shrimp… The Mac and cheese is okay, nothing to go crazy over as TikTok reviews may make it seem. The sweet potatoes taste more sugary than anything. The fish sandwich needs a signature sauce or something, as it’s relatively dry and lacks flavor. I’m open to trying more of their options tho.
Great customer service and the food was delicious. The fried lobster tail was the best, well seasoned, tender and delicious.
Disappointed. I ordered two pieces of fried whiting today via Uber Eats and this is what I received. Not only was the presentation bad, but so was the fish. It was dry and rubbery with no flavor at all. Makes me wonder if the fish was fake.
I've been going to this spot since the very first days it opened and the quality has steadily gone down. I'm guessing that due to inflation they probably had to adjust some recipes and whatnot but it's not the same anymore. If I have to wait over 45 minutes for food, I'd like it to have flavor at the very least. I used to faithfully get mac shrimp and bbq jerk chicken wings and in the few years they've been in operation I've seen the recipe to those (formerly) perfect dishes go DOWN. Before the recipe changes you could taste the succulent shrimp juices ALL throughout the CREAMY mac and cheese, now its dried out, the noodles were bland to the max and flavor was severely lacking. The old jerk BBQ had the thickest most luxurious and spicy taste ever and now the sauce is not the same anymore. I truly hope one day this place returns to the original recipes. Til then I will not spend upgraded prices on downgraded food.
Thanks.
The thing about this restaurant was not the food I ordered (I ordered fish & chips), it was all the food I didn't order. I saw some Delicious looking bake mac & cheese, candied yams, also some tasty looking salmon. I didn't sample any but the food sure looked appealing to taste. The staff was very friendly and generous with the giving of condiments. Cool vibes at this place!
The food is great but they never open on time i set n my car n waiting for them to open n still not open nor answer the phone to say they running behind or something
Customer service was excellent I called before I walked in answered my questions shared a laugh…very warm experience they treat city workers well
Ordered sweet Chili salmon excellent
This spot is ridiculously over priced. The food not worth the OVER PRICED FOOD. No combo meal…. The workers are not professional. They all have attitudes. I would never order from here again & I ACTUALLY LIVE AROUND HERE! I do not recommend. The amount of money and time you spend you should go to a restaurant.
I’m putting 5 STARS SO YOU GUYS CAN SEE MY ACTUAL RATING!
Do not recommend
Prices is way to high smh why are people putting they establishments in the hood to charge bougie outrageous prices good luck and food was just regular