Best Seafood Restaurant New York: reviews, page 2

The fish was succulent
The sushi was less so.
The servers are nice but a little lost.

Terrible take out service. Food was dry with no taste no dressing for the salad therefore also dry. The side had no complimentary sauces also dry. The...

Great food and service. Steaks are cooked perfectly every time. A bit $$$ If you have multiple drinks.

Huge thank you to Nolan's for being so accommodating and having such amazing food. I ordered their food for my dad's birthday party and they were...

Absolutely amazing best seafood in town! I have you recommend the jumbo shrimp and their lobster tail

Just had my dinner “experience” here. I can now die. I’ve had the best meal of my life! I am from a seaside town in Sicily and this fish was...

Staff is had the cowboy burger and Mahi tuna sandwiches along with a stuffed mushrooms w/ lobster. All excellent choices

Probably my fav spot to eat on Montauk: tasty, big portions, good service, simple yet cozy and nice, garden, pond, love it

I've been going to Umbertos for over 40 years. A must stop when in NYC. Love the calamari in spicy sauce and the best garlic biscuits!

Awesome seafood spot with impeccable service in a location you are least expecting to find it.

I was surprised, this was possibly the best meal I’ve had in Brooklyn (lived here for 2 years). I had a tuna tartar tostada and the sweet potato...

Great service, nice and clean setup. Could improve chicken seasoning. Chicken was cooked but the sauce was just thrown on it.

If you want fresh seafood this is a great place. Greek preparations were fantastic. Salmon, tuna, and halibut were cooked ro perfection. They catered...

Everything was great! We got there a half hour before closing and everything was top notch. Took their time, gave us great service. The steak was...

TV all over the place to watch the games. They have a parking lot and a patio at the back where we can eat beside the bar inside. Nice place to hang out...

Went here to celebrate my anniversary with the family and the restaurant exceed our expectations. We order the Fried Calamari, Linguine Fruit De Marie...

The steaks were cooked to the perfection. The appetizers and the sidedishes were excellent and the service was great. I would definitely go back for...

Thank you for fabulous service and AMAZING food! The vibes are great and the interior is beautiful.

Amazing service! We had barely drank any water before it was being refilled. Very attentive staff. Food was amazing! My only disappointment was that I didn’t...

Great food, great service, very little wait even though we went on a Sunday at 5: 30. The only complaint was that they were out of several drinks at the...