Shelter Island House, Shelter Island Heights NY

The Shelter Island House is beautiful! The front desk people are friendly, knowledgeable, helpful and professional. The hotel is walking distance to beautiful beaches and good food. Amazing for a weekend getaway. Looking forward to going back!

Last minute stay for 2 nights room was great. People were so nice. Although the restaurant was closed they were very helpful. I definitely recommend.

Shelter Island House is a wonderful establishment. The resort was conveniently located. Sunset Beach just minutes away walking distance. The resort's grounds very welcoming. The pool area was very relaxing. We also enjoyed the outdoor setting areas, especially with a nice glass of wine! Our room was clean and very comfortable. However, I should say the back outdoor lights kept me up a good part of the night. Maybe the next time I would bring eye mask covers. On the other hand, the staff was very attentive, accommodating, and friendly. The breakfast was light but pleasant. My husband and I would definitely return.

Amazing hotel, great service, beautiful rooms and accommodations. The breakfast was great and definitely recommend staying here.

I really only went to the restaurant, 18 Bay. Did not check out the rooms. 18 Bay is STILL my favorite place to dine!

A beautiful, quaint property for a lovely weekend getaway. My husband and I really enjoyed our time here - it was quiet, relaxing and very soothing. The birds chirping outside are such a treat and the property overall has really good vibes. The bed and sheets were very comfy. We explored the Island and Ram Island - visited beaches that felt private and biked our way around town. I 10/10 recommend. The bikes included were a great gesture but we rented our own for our longer haul bike plans. The staff is very kind especially the manager and Jimmy! Jimmy was very accommodating during dinner and just wanted us to have a great evening. It was very special and specific attention that most places can never offer.

Great place to stay but it is expensive and yet very clean. The restaurant is extremely expensive but worth it. The food is superb. The free breakfast doesn't consist of a lot of food. It consists of small pastries, tea, and coffee. Creasant beach is within walking distance and it is beautiful.

Traveled 6 months pregnant with my husband and 2.5 year old. Had the best time! The owner/ manager (Suzanne) was so accommodating, helped me load the car when my husband wasn’t there, gave us a late checkout so we can take our time, etc. Loved the pool and how easy towels, umbrellas were to obtain. Just quaint and lovely overall.

Nice room, very spacious with and a nice bathroom. Nice middle sized swimming pool, and they have free bath towels you can borrow.
The amount of people allowed at the pool and the breakfast had some new good rules because of COVID-19. Very friendly staff. The restaurant is closed (Covid regulations). All and all a good night there but quite pricy.

Always hospitable, relaxing pool area and cool Bar. Proximity to shopping and coffee bars and the beach. We will come back again and again.