Sheridan Family Restaurant, Amherst NY

Went there on a weeknight with two other people. The person who greeted us acted like she'd rather be anywhere but there, and basically threw the menus on the table while saying "your server will be with you" as she walked away. The server was friendly, but not very fast.

The food was not great. I ordered a burger cooked to medium, but got it well-done. The onion rings I ordered with it were good. Another member of my party got a chicken souvlaki salad, which she said was good. The other member go the Greek dinner, and it was barely edible. In addition, it took the server 5 or 6 tries to get all of our food and beverages delivered, and had to be reminded each time of what we were still missing.

The only positive is that they comped the really bad meal. I guess it's a good place to visit if you only want chicken souvlaki.

Went for lunch 11/22, table of 3. Food took 30 min to arrive after 10 min wait to order. Gyro Wraps were horrible - burnt, crumbly meat. Onion rings were great and tuna melt was good as well. Out of spanakopita. Nice server.

Food is always delicious here but you'd better be hungry! Dollar for dollar you really can't beat it. Daily specials also worth checking out.

Great local family friendly restaurant with really terrific food. So good its rare for customers to leave without wanting to take left overs home. Serving sizes are very generous.

Purchase a combination dinner asked for meat to be medium all the meat was burnt won't do that again

Order the cinnamon French toast. When the waitress tells you that it’s addictively good.
I concur that it is definitely delicious.

I called my order in at 12: 03 (open beef, Mediterranean melt, baklava). I was told it would be ready in 20-25 minutes. I went in at 12: 25 and they were pretty busy. I waited in line for a little more than 5 minutes before someone asked to help me. I gave them my name and was told my order wasn't ready, it would be another 10 minutes. I went out to my car and waited 15 minutes before going back in. When I got in, I asked if my order was ready, it was not. Eventually I got my order and asked if the baklava was in there.it wasn't. At 1: 00 I walked out with my order. I got home at 1: 10 and discovered there was no dressing for the salad and the melt was cold.
This was unusual for this place. My wife and I order out from here frequently and have never had a problem. We understand they were very busy and short staffed. It's quite frustrating waiting for an hour to get a food order only to find it is incomplete and less than expected. Again, normally we don't have any problems here.

I've been to this diner a few times now and each time the food has been okay. The food wasn't bad but wasn't anything special. I had pancakes and hashbrowns and they were bland. I did try lunch with them and that was better. I heard that they have an amazing chicken souvlaki so I would suggest trying that. The staff is really friendly and does make it more of an enjoyable experience. The atmosphere is 100% diner although it does feel really dated inside so it is charming but might not be everyones cup of tea. I would go back and try more. I think it is worth checking out especially since the food isn't costly.

The brunette waitress that was sick and coughing turned me off so bad on eating, I walked right out after my coffee.

Very disappointed! The food was not good. Service was good & it was clean. Best part of meal was the coffee. Do not go here. So sad.

Food was great but it took Almaty 10 minutes for our waitress to come over. Other people that were seated after were taken care of first

I truly love this place! ALWAYS consistent with unbeatable prices. I’ve been many times, haven’t been let once. Can’t wait to come back!

We waited 45 minutes for a breakfast order. Wasn’t even that busy. Would not come back unless you have an hour and a half to kill

We stopped in with a large party of 8 on a very busy Sunday morning after church. A table was available shortly after we waited after they pushed 3 together. This was our first time eating at the restaurant. The menu was huge with a wonderful variety of breakfast, lunch and dinner selections plus many side choices.

Our waitresses was busy as she had tables and booths in all corners of the dining room. Drinks arrived and our orders were taken. We waited quite awhile but we could tell the restaurant was crowded and the kitchen we're sure was busy preparing the orders as they came in. One of our party ordered a sandwich and an order of French fries which didn't come when the sandwich arrived. Those who ordered breakfast entrees waited at least five minutes after the sandwich orders came out. One of our party ordered a dinner entree and that came out 10 minutes after the sandwiches. Again, the place was packed. The fries finally arrived shortly afterwards. Kind of weird that the orders came out like they did. Otherwise, everything was ok. The food was good. Our waitress did as best as she could. Hopfully if we come back, the place won't be as crowded and we can enjoy eating our meals together!

Good food, friendly staff. Hearty portions, I got two nicely cooked overeasy eggs, lots of home fries, lots of bacon (6 or 7 slices) and toast. Wife go short stack of pancakes, 2 almost plate size pancakes

Small cozy place to get delicious breakfast. Service and food was excellent. We went on a Sunday morning and had to wait as the place was packed. The 15-20 min wait was worth it.