Simply Greekalicious, Wantagh NY

The food gave me food poisoning and then when I called the restaurant to let them know, they answered in a humorous response, and said that it didn’t happen to anybody else

We have been ordering here for a few years now without issue. On tonight's $80 order they left out two gyros that were ordered, left us on hold for 5 minutes. Then had to drive back and forth for another 25 mins. Missed dinner with my family and not so much as an apology from them. Time to find somewhere else.

Ordered the beef and lamb gyro.probably the best gyro I've ever had. Highly recommend.

First time having and will definitely be back!
Food is insanely delicious!
Love!

My husband and I have been ordering fro here for awhile usually we do delivery because food is good but tonight I was informed it would be an additional 3.95 delivery charge which is outrageous and that does not include tip for the driver so I went to pick up the food and the same order a week ago for 2 people was 7 dollars more even paying cash…. For what they charge there are other options many with free delivery … saddly we will no longer be going there due to price increases! From now on we will go to Abe’s for half the price and free delivery.

20 dollars for a gyro and small order of fries is crazy. With that being said the food was good. Gyro meat was very flavorful and fries were cooked just right. If it wasn't so expensive I'd be back.

Quite possibly some of the WORST Greek food I've ever eaten. Ordered a Greek salad to go and the bottom of the plastic to go tray was filled with easily a Quarter inch of water, who the hell serves salad with water like that? The lettuce was all soggy and the salad was ruined. Friggin Gross. The chicken that came with the salad had the consistency of a rubber band too. Just flat out disgusting food. NEVER again. Garbage.

Terrible service. Got our order wrong and didn’t even offer to fix it. Overpriced for such low quality as well

The lunch specials really helped the cost to be more reasonable. The chicken gyro lunch special was a great size and was delicious. Gyro had a lot of tzatziki if you like that (I do). The lunch special with spinach pie and greek salad was good too but definitely a lot less food compared to the gyro. The spicy feta app was good but the chips were too aggressively seasoned. I probably would skip that next time. Service was friendly and fairly quick. A few small tables available for dine in.

Ordered online. Food was great. Portions were on the smaller side for the platter. A bit expensive when ordering online because of Grub Hub.

After going to Abe’s for the past 30 years. Lately it’s been going way down hill so we decided to try this place out. My favorite new place! The food and service is wonderful. Thanks guys.