St James Bagels

Got a nice BEC with Avocado on Everything Bagel. The service was fast and friendly. I couldn't have asked for a better experience

Great bagels and the service is good too. I make sure to stop there and bring bagels back home to Philly area when I visit my friend in St. James.

Always delicious. So many selections. Always busy. The best bagels in Smithtown. Blows Beans bagels away!

It's a bagel shop so idk how much atmosphere it's supposed to have, but you're definitely comfortable at the cafe tables.

Food is delicious and generously sized.

Service is friendly and they listen to how you like your order (lightly toasted or a little butter or a lot of mayo or whatever your thing is).

I drive up from Selden if I'm having a bad day and their BLT on a bagel fixes everything. I take it on a toasted everything and get the cucumber salad as my side. The rest of the day the Sun shines brighter and my colleagues seem nicer. And the bagels and bacon portion are large enough to save half for dinner if I'm working late.

Best bagels, best sandwiches, workers are amazing. I will drive out of my way to go there.

Wonderful hard working and friendly servers w/best bagels in town.
Thank you always. Jeff and Annie

This place is awesome, best egg everything bagels I've had. I only wish they were open later (:

Excellent bagels, fairly quick service, owners stepped in to help service on busy Sunday morning.

Fantastic options in terms of bagels and spreads. The staff here is very attentive and awesome.

I used to love this place but they kept messing my order up. This is the 3rd time. I ordered a BACON egg and cheese sandwich and they put no bacon on it. Then the owner sent the delivery driver back and asked for the old sandwich back to make sure there was actually no bacon on it. Are you kidding me? Stop screwing up peoples orders and do your job correctly before you come and question a customer who has gave you so much business. Never ever ordering from here again.

Great place. Ordered a cheese burger and hot chocolate that reminded me of when I was younger and the guy was extremely nice and caring. It’s close and convenient amazing place 10/10.

Might be the best bagel place in town, only out of three bagel stores, but make sure you order ahead unless you are prepared to wait 27 minutes for two breakfast sandwiches.

Suffolk is packed with bagel shops, and believe me I've tried them all.
There's no reason to go anywhere but this place! The service is unfailingly friendly and prompt, the food is excellent, and the rye bagels in particular are the best I've ever had!
If you're ANYWHERE nearby, this is where to eat.

I just ordered the ruben pressed with swiss cheese. Mustard, saurket, and russian on the side. A pickle and macaroni on the side. It was so yummy. Who ever made my sandwich. Thank u…

I’m not sure how people think these bagels are good but they’re not. We ordered breakfast sandwiches, the bacon was so fatty I could not eat it they did not toast the bagel and the bagel was rubbery… paid 16 bucks for two breakfast sandwich bagels that were just blah

Worst bagel I have ever had. Ordered bagels and a few other things with some friends and every one of our items tasted like dirty sink water. Would never recommend coming here.