The Ice Cream Tree, Mayfield NY

This was the best restaurant ever! I went with my family and friends for dinner and ice cream. Everything was priced very low and the portions were HUGE! I ordered an Oreo marshmallow malt milkshake and it was by far the best milkshake I ever had. I also ordered a small calzone for about $10, and it was so big it didn’t even fit on the pizza plate. I had 3 dinners from that one calzone and it was really good. Everyone else loved their food. I would 100% recommended this place to everyone and will definitely be back soon. I put my hand next to the calzone for size reference.

Camping at Northampton a bad thunderstorm was on the way so we left the campsite and went here for ice cream. We waited out the storm at the Northville boat launch ate our ice cream and returned to our site all was good and we built a camp fire.

Delicious pizza and burgers. Ice Cream is also very good. They do their best with minimal staff and being busy.

Always consistent. Specials are very good and creative. Pizza has a airy crust and toppings are generous.

1st time stopping on our trip of north and will definitely make it a part of our trips from now on.

Extra creamy and thick soft serve ice cream, great pizza and a delicious menu! Casual. Eat in or take out $$

They never have the ice cream they advertise. Every single time I’ve been there they’re out of at LEAST 5 different flavors, sometimes more. No matter what time of the summer, beginning middle or end, they have never had all the ice cream flavors available. Has become quite a disappointment to say the least!