The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza, Staten Island NY

Ordered the Goodfellow signature pizza. I didn't realize they would be skimpy on the toppings. I didn't care for the mussels. It tasted frozen. Service was okay. We were forgotten in the corner.

Best pepperoni pie ever! Sauce unlike any I've ever tasted. Crust, cheese and pepperoni top quality. Ruined me for my local pizza shop.

This place was delicious and the service was great! An authentic Italian-American joint. I had the pizza alla vodka and a huge Long Island ice tea and enjoyed the chuck mangione music playing in the background. Prices were very reasonable for the portion size too. I’m still dreaming about returning. Go here, you won’t regret it.

Omggg I am still sitting here with my husband, catching a break from the kids lol…I couldn’t wait to leave my review. I still can’t believe how amazing this Pizza is. The service was excellent! The pizza was so flavorful and the bread is so soft Wowwww! First time here in all the years I’m in Staten island but I’m coming back. My recommendation is to Try the vodka pizza/chicken cheddar square (not sure the exact name). The calamari is another amazing appetizer. Thank you!

Literally one of the worst restaurants on staten island.very bland food you can Tell this is an old person restaurant.

Lobster bisque has literally no lobster and absolutely no seasoning what a shame.

The lunch specials are a true bargain. I ordered a garden salad and Veal Milanese. The portions were plentiful.and the food tasted great. A carbonated beverage is included, all for $12.99. The service was excellent and the staff were smiling and friendly.
Give it a shot when you are in the area. You will be glad you did.

After having the Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza, I don't want any other pizza from somewhere else, I just want the Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza. Now I know why they are the world champion for pizza!

Pizza, salad, cocktails & dessert were all great! Service was super friendly. Looking forward to returning and visiting their new space when it opens!

My favorite pizza anywhere. They offer a Gluten Free version of their original gourmet pizzas, which makes me so happy. I.mived out of Staten Island and come back periodically w my family foe their delicious pizza and other Italian dishes.

I passed by and I'd ask for a slice and a soda and was my lucky day because Mr Scott gave me a whole personal pizza on the house. Of course I'll be back

I love their personal pizzas. I also do catering & have yet to have an issue. Food always arrives hot, not spilt or damaged & estimated time is usually on point. Food is good/no compliants. Definitely worth a try if you've never had them.

Best pizza ever! Staff was wonderful and couldn’t have had a better experience. When in Statin Island…. It’s a definite must.