The Pastry Box, New York NY

Amazing place. The s’mores cookie was one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. Right up there with Levain cookies in my opinion (my favorite spot, but too crowded these days). Delicious crunch on the edges. Soft and gooey in the middle. A nice layer of creamy marshmallows and rich chocolate chunks. A light coarse sea salt on top to give it that savory crunch. I got two expecting to share one with my friend but ended up eating both myself. Can’t wait to come try more goodies.

The best bakery ever! The strawberry shortcake bites are to die for. Very fresh. Highly recommend.

This bakery is fantastic & so is Tiara. I had a chocolate cake made for my birthday and it was delicious. On top of that, the customer service is TOP NOTCH. Will be back soon!

I just had two delicious cookies here - the chocolate chip and the black and white. They were flavorful, moist, and rich; and I can't decide which one was my favorite. The owner, Tiara, is a bundle of positive energy. I hope this new business finds the success it deserves.

Absolutely DELICIOUS! Tiara and her crew are beyond amazing! We asked for a pond theme/color cake for our daughter’s first birthday and it was just the cutest smash cake! We had cupcakes as well and Tiara had asked what flavor cupcakes we wanted, being pregnant I asked for strawberry matcha as one flavor and carrot cake for the other. They were outstanding! They were so well and balanced flavor and a huge hit with our guests. Of course we had to grab some other goodies when we picked up our order and it was a great preview to what was to come! The mini apple pies were so perfectly bite-sized and packed with flavor. The chocolate chip cookie is a classic and Tiara nailed it! Everything is just amazing. Such a treat to have The Pastry Box!

This is my favorite bakery in Nyc. It is cozy and the team is friendly and welcomes you with a big smile.
The quality of the coffee is on point and everything is baked in the house. Highly recommend you “The pastry box”.

Only got the banana bread but will be back to try the other things! The banana bread was not too wet or sweet which is hard to come by.

Such an amazing experience! This bakery is new, but I foresee that this bakery will join the ranks of the greatest bakeries in NYC in due time. Their brown butter brownie was addictive, and their 1/4 lb chocolate chip cookie was the best cookie i've ever had. The chef's tastes must perfectly align with mine. The cookie had deliciously high-quality, ooey gooey chocolate chips that were perfectly balanced with sea salt. The cookie itself had a great texture that was satisfyingly thick while not being too cakey or, alternatively, too crunchy or hard. I also had the great privilege of speaking to the chef who was so kind! She gave me a complimentary scoop of gelato after I shared with her how much I enjoyed my experience. Trying out this bakery was one of the best and most wholesome experiences of my summer in NYC, and I highly recommend it to anyone in the vicinity of the East Village or Manhattan in general!

Awesome. Smores cookie with perfect chew, great sweet/salty balance. Dagel was perfect, the dough was nice and moist, filling flavorful and not overwhelming. Will definitely come back again-as a person who rarely is a return customer, that’s saying something!

New cutest place in the hood, love the weekends doughnuts, mmmmmm, delicious, also like the cheese scones, highly recommended.

Fantastic and creative baked goods, solid cold brew, and lovely owner/lead baketress. Top picks (so far) : banana bread with choc, choc chip cookie, and “dagel” (savory donut with seasonal fillings like tomato dill). Great new neighborhood spot!

Tiara is very kind and her pastries are exquisite! So glad to have The Pastry Box in the neighborhood!

A cheerful space and a cheerful business owner serving delicious and beautiful pastries. Tiara's bakes were a delight in Bed Stuy and the East Village is now lucky to have her. My personal favorites are the donuts and yuzu olive oil loaf, but you can't go wrong whatever you get here.

Such an excellent new bakery! The raspberry muffin and yuzu olive oil cake were fantastic and the owner was so sweet. Cannot wait to go back!

The desserts are Absolutely Amazing!

The most exquisite ingredients, flavors, and taste. I had the blueberry filled donut, the berries inside taste farm fresh and the pastry was so dainty & delicate.

The beautiful natural lighting and atmosphere is a must have too. I will DEFINITELY visit again.

I got the sour cherry tart and a cold brew, both were excellent! Very cute shop and the owner was friendly and welcoming. Everything is baked in house! Definitely stop by and try it out!

New Bakery Alert! I love this bakery. It doesn’t get cuter than this place. And the treats so ridiculously delicious. You have to give this place a try whenever you’re in the area. The owner is such a sweetheart and it’s been a long time since I had this positive of an experience in NYC. I will be telling all my friends