Tilly's Table, Brewster NY

Colleen was a pleasure to work with to assist in hosting a baby shower here during Sunday Brunch for 25 people. She was pleasant, responsive and helpful with the whole process. The food was great and everyone had a great time. Our main server, George, took care of everything and answered any questions we had. Highly recommend for a small or large group.

This was a beautiful venue. The food was great, it was endless mimosas and unlimited appetizers. The service was great as well. I will definitely will be coming back.

Waitstaff was busy but attentive. Food was delicious with very generous portions. Desserts were amazing and not overly sweet. Cappuccino was divine. We can’t want to return again for a family meal.

Nice place. Good food and large portions. Went for Sunday brunch.
Meal starts at a Farmers table witch is a buffet with appetizers.
I attached pictures. Crab cakes, Nutella waffles, steak and eggs, farmers omlet. All served with bacon and home fries.
They were serving Mamosas at the tables. Minor complain, staff never came over to see if we wanted something different to drink, Like a soda. I'm sure I could of waved them down. They are real busy.
It's a working farm and the have some animals outside like llamas and chickens that you can take the kiddies out to see.
The food and the atmosphere was well worth the visit. Next time I'll wear stretch pants.

This is a beautiful place that can accommodate a larger party. The wait staff was excellent, but the food wasn't. I had such high hopes too! The appetizers were mediocre - pork belly that wasn't trimmed well and was tough; a great big pretzel that was good, but served with Gulden's mustard straight from the bottle, and stuffed clams which seemingly had no clams, only breading.
The enteees were worse. Granted, the short ribs were excellent according to three of the people at our table, but anything seafood related just wasn't good - octopus that was almost inedible because of its texture and lobster mac-n-cheese that was gooey, mushy and watery all at the same time. Coffee at the end was an actual abomination to the beverage, like it had been sitting in the pot since lunch service.

Love this place! I've been to events in the barn and dinners at the restaurant. The entire property is beautiful, and in addition to the delicious food, the service/staff are wonderful. HIGHLY recommend this place for an event, dinner, or even a quick drink! Great vibes all around.

My family has been hyping this place up so I was excited to finally go. However I must say I was a little disappointed.
We each ordered salads to start and an order of baked clams along with some seasonal drinks. The salads were great, we had the beet, burrata and rughetta salads, however, the clams were a bit burned. They were also nothing special. For entrees we has the short ribs, martini chicken, and the shrimp scampi. My short ribs were great and cooked perfect. The pastas however, were not. The pasta in the shrimp scampi was severely undercooked while the pasta in the chicken martini was overcooked. The drinks were pretty good though some in the group said they were too sweet. The service was great and our waiter was excellent and very attentive, he’s probably the only reason this is a 4 star and not 3 star review.
I’m told by those in my party this was not a typical Tilly’s experience. They say that usually everything is excellent, so maybe we just caught them on an off day. And to be fair, my food (salad+short ribs) was all pretty good but the rest of my party couldn’t say the same. But i would personally give Tilly’s another try.

Attended the Octoberfest at Tilly's last night. Despite the cold temps the whole evening was great. Venue is nice, food was much better than expected, warm up singer was outstanding and the Billy Joel tribute band was terrific. Will be back for more outdoor events.

I went to a concert there. It was a Pat Benatar cover band. They were outstanding! Beautiful day, beautiful setting, excellent time!

We attended a 40th birthday gathering. Dinner began with a fried Calamari Marinara appetizer, which was excellent. Crispy, not at all oily, with a tasty marinara. There was a second appetizer, which I barely touched. (Sorry, the Calamari was so good!) Entrées were Penne Vodka, Steak, Chicken and Salmon, all served with garlic mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables. Everything was farm fresh and absolutely delectable. I must mention the stringbeans were cooked to perfection. The only challenge were the acoustics. I had to take breaks on the roomy porch several times, it's a very open floor plan with high ceilings and a dining area on the first floor open to where we were seated on the second floor. Rough on volume. Service was excellent and friendly.

First time going- what a beautiful view! Food was yummy! Service was awesome- shout out to Corey who was so attentive and engaging!

Looking forward to returning soon!

The food was amazing. I had the farm to table beef tenderloin and my husband had the surf and turf and we both finished our plates. They were also very accommodating of my 2 year old and it was great to go see the animals after we were done eating!

This is a beautiful place! They have indoor and outdoor dining. They do have live music on some nights. It would be a great venue for dates or families. The staff were very friendly and the food prices are reasonable. I would highly recommend and will return soon.

I give it 2 stars for the beautiful view and ambiance, but it was a mediocre breakfast at best and the “farmers buffet” was ordered and highly unlikely to be homemade. It all reminded me of pastries and snacks from ACE Endico. Beautiful, but the food was disappointing.

Went here a fun little festival. Lovely place with a lovely gift shop that also holds classes. The bar/restaurant looks terrific, with beautiful outdoor seating. In the summer they have Saturday night concerts on the green.check the website for details.

Tilly’s did an outstanding job for our wedding reception. The space is gorgeous, the staff is so accommodating and kind, and the food is incredible. We got lots of comments that this was the best wedding food that any of our guests had ever experienced. It was a spectacular night.

Went to Tilly's with a group of Friends to the Sunday Brunch and we all loved it. Had a great time and the food was delicious. They had great menu choices and a large buffet of baked items items to explore. Nummies! Afterwards we walked the spacious grounds seeing all the different farm animals and beautiful horses. They also had a nice gift shop on the property. Thank you Tilley's for the wonderful afternoon!