Tony's Di Napoli

This is one of my favorite places for Fettuccini Alfredo, but it's a hit or a miss depending on the time you visit here. The reason I say that is because at times their alfredo sauce is really good and other times, usually after 8 pm, it gets a lot more salty. I wished they went a little easy on the salt so we could enjoy the complete flavor of the pasta and sauce. I would have given it 5 stars but the quality of their food and service is a bit inconsistent.

Great atmosphere and very friendly hostess and wait staff. Good value for money, $29 for a huge plate of spaghetti pomodore which feeds three.

Nice location pre Broadway show but food is just average.very very big portions but not very very tasty

Great place, food is amazing and portion sizes are for sharing so don't be put off by what appears high price, it's actually excellent value for money and great tasting food. Place is huge inside which makes for a vibrant atmosphere. Riad, the waiter has an amazing voice if your lucky enough to heat him belt out a happy birthday tribute to someone highly recommended.

My first time eating here and it was such a great experience. The food is delicious and the service is excellent!

The place was packed. Very loud. The wine was mispriced on my menu, charging $5 kore than my menu said. The pasta alfredo was literally the worst I have ever had. It was almost gritty. Too starchy. The Mozz in Corroza was just friend cheese triangles. We each ate a few fork fulls, had them pack it up and we donated the takeaway. $60 in food.it was that bad.

Beautiful Italian cuisine though limited vegetarian options. Chefs and waiters were enthusiastic and so loving, yes loving! The one who served us was musical and very special.

Top-notch Italian restaurant at Times Square. We had a large group so we ate Family style, but all 6-7 of the dishes were excellent.

We spent Christmas Eve at Tony's. This was our first time there and it simply isn't enough to say this place is amazing! Family style eating. A couple will have 4 meals to eat. The chicken parm was outstanding. I thought for being in the city, the prices were more than decent. Reservations, obviously were a must for a Saturday night (Xmas Eve)

I rarely leave a 5 star review, but this place gets it across the board. Me and my girlfriend were looking for a nice place to dine after walking Time Square, and something that was within reasonable price. Our server was awesome, and food/ portions were even better! I will recommend this place to everyone I know who will be visiting the City!

Just delicious.this is our new favorite italian restaurant in NY.big portions wonderful location cozy place and unique food.beside the paste you must try the octopus.make sure to call and book your table before you go so you don’t need to wait too much.

Unbelievable meal, fantastic service, amazing ambience. Definitely make reservations or you won't get in. Tried the lobster pasta (can't remember the name, was on the specials menu) which was PHENOMENAL, and the chicken parm which was easily the best i've ever had.

Server was amazing. Restaurant is gorgeous. Quite the experience.

5 star plus experience. Can't wait to go back!

Tony's is family style so they had very large portions at good prices. We had several different items and all were very good (we ordered 4 plates for 5 people and finished none of them to give you a sense of size). The key negative experience for us visiting Tony's was sitting in the basement, which is where a majority of their large parties were seated. The basement was extremely loud with low ceilings and being adjacent to the kitchen. It really hurt our experience. Additionally, while the servers did their best to be attentive, they were also working with two large parties (10+) nearby and that limited our contact (we weren't able to get more drinks). If we were to return, we would only do so seated upstairs in the main dining room.

A totally different place. The show when a waiter sang something like opera fascinated me. From today it will be one of my most frequent places to visit.

Had a great time at Tony Di Napoli. The only complaint I have is that the chicken picatta was way overcooked and dry. The calamari was great and the pasta was great as well! I am returning in August and looking forward to trying other items.

Amazing restaurant, food really good, big plates, enough for 2 person's, flavor and seasoning is good, service is friendly.

I had an impromptu dinner here with a friend and we had amazing time. Although they were not taking any more table seating we were able to enjoy dinner at the bar. The service was amazing, the drinks were on point and the food was delicious. The portions are quite hearty, you'll be full for sure or have leftovers.