Underdog, New York NY

Great little bar for a cocktail or quick bite. Had a few drinks and good conversation with our bartender. Would return and try some of the seasonal drinks.

Great bar food!
We went on a weekday and it wasn't too busy.
The servers were super nice and the beer on tap was great. I recommend the dogfish IPA.

Loved the experience! The staff was great! The burger was one of the best burgers I have had. Can't wait to go back.

Great atmosphere and great staff. Very knowledgeable on fun interesting drinks that taste great.

I like the place for what it is, a nice pub to meet friends. However, considering it costs 18$ the burger, it could be Bigger, Better and the fries could be cooked close to the moment when they are served rather than fried again or heated again. They were even cold. Bread stale too. Took super long even though the place was empty. Meat overcooked as well. Might have been a rough Monday.

Watch out! Credit card theft! Two cards used at this location had their information stolen and fraudulent charges were made.

Cool bar on stone street. We had couple of beers on tap and I tried devil dog cocktail too. Delicious.

The food was OK, nothing much. Service was terrible. Staff clearly didn't have any skills to work with people as if they were doing you a favour.

Wonderful time down here on Stone St in the financial district of NYC! Food and drinks and music and women and the doorman, even, augmented my experience.

We had the best experience. Angel was our waiter and he was so friendly, funny and made us feel at home. He gave us the best directions to the subway. I LOVED the vegan cauliflower Buffalo wings and the vegan sliders. My girls had a BLT and Burger. Both loved their meal too. The house potato chips are AMAZING! You need to sell those things in stores!

Despite it’s location in the center of global finance, this place is a respite from the typical; they have loads of vegan options, and the service is pretty on-point. Don’t come in a hurry, though.

Great place. Love the music. The food is all great. The impossible sliders taste better than most burgers. The cauliflower wings are worth going alone. Good selection of beers and well crafted cocktails.

We came off Governors Island ferry after a few drinks there and decided to find a place to grab a bite. We chose Underdog totally at random via maps. There is a lot of different places right on the same block downtown, and we had to try our luck. Place seemed clean, clean restroom, wasn't too busy for Columbus Day night, around 7ish PM. No overwhelming music, so you can have a convo. Food was decent. I ordered a portobello burger, thinking its gonna be one big mushroom like you grill at home, but instead it was multiple slices ordeal, which went every which way off your bun. Fries were great. My wife enjoyed beef burger. I understand this is a bar, but we didn't want a drink, being already pretty smashed, and I don't like explaining to snooty waiters WHY aren't we ordering drinks. Water is just fiiiine. Another surprise came with the bill. We go out pretty regularly, but I rarely see gratuity alredy INCLUDED into my Total at 20%. Some places include 10-15% for "parties of 6 or more" and they also advertise that on the menu, this wasn't the case. So not only the 20% gratuity included into the bill like its some minor charge, below it I saw a line for ADDITIONAL TIPS and below a line for TOTAL. Was this made for rich drunks that can't see too well at the closing time, or this is a new practice? My additional tip is that you're surrounded by ton of other places for us to check out next time, and your wait staff wasn't topless, I really could not justify ADDITIONAL TIPS unto our bill for bringing us two burgers and fried pickles appetizer, which by the way was good but half of the plate was string beans that my wife hates, so I was on bean duty. My mushroom burger also had no lettuce or tomato, because with chopped mushrooms this thing would just end up in my lap after first bite, so I kinda get it. This is just a poor execution, I guess this is a choice for vegetarians, better than nothing, but I'm not a vegetarian so to me this was a fail choice. 3 stars out of 5 for the overall experience, and we both argeed that we will not be popping in any time soon.

Love this place. Been going for a few years Recently waited a long time for my soup and had to flag down another server. It was cold as if sitting there for a while

We went to the downstairs area and it was really beautiful. Loved the decor and lighting. Food and cocktail menu seemd great, we ordered the fried pickles that also included other fried vegetables and we were there for it. It was really delicious. I won't judge the cocktails because we only had a glass of white wine which we also really enjoyed. My critique is about the staff. I have never encountered such rude, aloof, and unaware group of people. No one even said "hello" when we got there, nor even when we ordered. We sat at the bar and the bartender (woman) was so so rude and short with us and to the couple next to us. There was a very personal conversation between her and one of the servers that was so inappropriate to have in front of patrons. Bartender took very long even though she was right in front of us, to see us so we could order the appetizer that we almost didn't. Every other place in the area was very crowded except for this one and I could tell that service was the issue.
This place has great potential as long as they keep the right staff around. Our visit was on Tuesday 8/23/22

Best bar in the fidi hands down. Matthew is amazing. Makes soothing drinks and a fun guy to talk with. Marko and Javier is great alongside Alison. Overall I'll definitely recommend people to take a look at this place. The food and drinks and the music won't disappoint you. It's a vibe you don't wanna miss out on

Love the atmosphere of stone street but always had a hard time finding vegan food there. They had many options and they were all delicious.