Wagon Wheel Pizza, Wappingers Falls NY

Best pizza in the village. It’s the only place my kids want to go for pizza. He makes a decent salad. I usually order the eggplant parm sandwich and I’d say it’s the best eggplant parm that I’ve had since I moved to New York in 2018.

Love their pizza. The place has that authentic feel to it. FYI -It a cash only business if you do plan on visiting.

Pizza is priced well but cash only. Owner is chill nice to speak with. Doesn't look like much when you walk in, but it's very tasty.

We stopped by for slices on a Friday night at around 10pm. The pizza was pretty good and the dough was perfect! The owner was very friendly and accommodating

Stop in after cornhole game. Pizza was amazing! I’m a Bronx girl and been up here 15 years…can’t believe I didn’t try sooner!

Wagon Wheel Pizza in the village of Wappingers Falls is very tasty pizza. You can buy it by the slice or pie. Of course, you can keep your pizza with cheese only or order toppings for a nominal amount extra.
It's important to mention that you must pay cash only; credit cards not accepted.

Love Wagon Wheel, one of my favorite pizza places as a kid and have to get Wagon Wheel every time I come back to visit. The pizza is as great now as it was then

HANDS DOWN AMAZING PIZZA!
When you walk into the place your like um what the heck did I walk into.
One pizza oven, one guy, pizza made to order this isn't gonna be good
BUT let me say I've eaten at many pizzerias up and down the east coast.
Wagon Wheel Pizza is easily in top 3 if not the BEST! I was literally in shock and blown away by how good it was. I'll be back here many many times!
Keep it up Pete!

The owner Pete is so nice my daughter and I wanted a couple slices each and he made a fresh pie for us just four slices thanks Pete

First time eating here and OMG! The Sicilian with extra cheese was AWESOME! The cheese was REAL GOOEY TASTY CHEESE! Not that cheese that looks translucent especially when it gets cold! The dough was so tasty! I usually throw the crust away because it’s dry or hard or burnt! BUT NOT this crust! It was AMAZING! Crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside.very very tasty! Will definitely be back for another pie!

Folks moved us to W. F.when I was born in '73. Grew up from then on with Wagon Wheel as a family staple of what pizza/Italian dishes should be- best around.
Move back here in my late 40's- hasn't changed, the sauce & dough. Still the best around and wouldn't go anywhere else, cuz pizza.

No other pizzeria could compare! This family run place is always kind and welcoming to customers new and old. The pizza itself is so fresh, and made right in front of you. The crust is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and the sauce is nothing like other places. Would highly recommend coming here! Heads up: cash-only! Yes, atm is available.

The past month I've eaten at 14 different pizzerias from fishkill, east fishkill, beacon, wappingers and poughkeepsie. None compare to this. Pizza has the right amount of crisp. No FLOP. It's not oily and dripping everywhere.

Oh and I only paid $11.50 for a large cheese pie.

Delicious Pizza and Pete the owner is friendly, polite, and at time funny. Prices are very reasonable

The pizza was worthy of the Bronx truly old school pizza place you can watch them make the pizza and toss it in front of you while you sit at the counter or at your booth.
The night we went it was just the owner and he did it all made the pizza and waited the tables. The pizza was delicious and sauce had nice flavor, the crust was crispy and not to thick nor to thing and folded perfectly.

I am in my 50's and remember my mom bringing me to the Wagon Wheel as a very young boy after she made her trip to the Mid Hudson Savings Bank on Mill St. I think the interior has remained the same through the years. Pete makes excellent pizza. You can also purchase fresh pizza dough to make at home (also excellent!)

Amazing owner. Foods greet, and the prices are better than most of the pizza places in the area.