Wild Things Pet Shop, New York Mills NY

Very dirty, did not have the critters they say they have. The only cool thing was the owners dogs.

This guy is the real deal. I'm just starting out with fish and he is very knowledgeable and no frills. Tells you the problem, and then the solution. Do what he says and you will have happy wild things!

Great assortment of fish and pet care equipment. Some of the reptile enclosures/care could be better, but everything is pretty reasonably priced.

Amazing customer service, I’ll definitely be coming back here! I’ve been struggling to find a good diet for my crested gecko and the staff here were able to give some really helpful advice, thanks guys!

Locally owned pet shop with a wonderful variety of animals. Being in business for so long, they are extremely helpful for any of your hobbyist needs. Miles better than any large commercial stores in the area.

If I could give this place zero stars I would the experience was horrible customer service horrible the salt water and freshwater tanks were disgusting. Owners asked us to leave after we started taking pictures of the filthy tanks for review. DONT BUY FROM THIS PLACE! The fish look neglected I worked at a coral reef place in south Florida and I’ve never seen fish look so bad!

Fantastic people, super knowledgeable and stand behind all of their products. Only pet store we buy are fish and corals from.

By far the best pet store within 100 miles. I only buy my fish, products and saltwater corals and fish from Bill and his wife. Very trustworthy ans knows his stuff. I have spent a lot of money here and will continue to do so because of knowledge and trust. Support local business and not corporate. Never had one issue and they are always there to help and give good advice. Been in the fish hobby for 35 years and they are one of the best in the business.

He's the only one who carries saltwater in the area! Great guy love his shop! I'll be there shortly to see the new marine section he just added!

Best pet shop in the area! Bill is super knowledgeable and is the nicest guy around. Would recommend to everybody and anybody

Absolutely love this pet shop. Knowledgeable owner, his wife is awesome as well. The selection of fish, reptiles, aquariums and equipment, corals, and other animals is extensive and more exotic than you can find at ANY other pet store in the area. The fish tanks could DEFINITELY use a good cleaning and some of the fish are kept in too crowded of an environment. Both easy fixes. I’ve only ever had one fish from her, an angel fish, die and I think it was because of my water or something in my tank, not because of anything related to the pet shop. All in all, this place is great. Great owners, great pet selection, great atmosphere, and great shopping experience. Highly highly recommend!

Awesome place for fish, maybe reptiles too. I was just blown away by the selection of fish. I've stocked my whole tank with just fish from there. A+ service and a great experience. Will definitely be back!

Local fish n reptile store. Good service, owner will help out with any questions you have.

I had bought feeder for our snakes and the mice was turning black and the fur was white but before they were turning our baby snake ate it and then throw it up then the next day had passed away and we payed alot of money for her

Lots of selection! The tanks are mostly full of algae everywhere but not so sure if that's a bad thing as the water is still clear and the fish are healthy. I've bought quite a few freshwater fish over the last few months and none of them have died or gotten sick (neon tetras, glass catfish, upside down catfish, severum, electric blue acara, amano shrimp, nerite snails, bettas, african dwarf frogs, german blue ram). Meanwhile the fish I've bought from petsmart have mostly died.

Owner is easy going and can help you out with any advice you need. Actually, when I bought my electric blue acara he looked at the tank and suggested I wait another week or so just to make sure they weren't sick. They're not cheap fish and him being honest about not buying them right away means quite a bit to me.

The place is bad and you can’t see them there are died fish they don’t take care of the fish and don’t give the beta fish enough room

DONT BUY FROM THUS PLACE they take horrible care of their animals and you can’t see the fish in the aquariums

Very disappointed! I did not purchase anything because of how poorly kept the animals were. The fish tanks look like they have never been cleaned, they were filled with nasty water and had alge grown all over the tanks. Some tanks you couldnt even see the fish. I didnt bother to talk to the owner, I was so furious with the animal abuse going on in the shop. I was excited to see they had a big tank for the koi however the tank was absolutely disgusting and there were to many fish for the space of the tank, I'm truly sad with how these animals are being treated.
I understand its hard to keep up with so many tanks but it was ridiculous!