Carfagna's Kitchen, Columbus OH

Not great, but not the worst food I've ever eaten. It is just bland all around, which might be OK for some people. We tried the pizza and spaghetti & meatballs. The meatballs were cold, but my 3 year old did like them. The sauce on the spaghetti and the pizza was bland. The crust on the pizza was not very good. I probably wouldn't be back. The service was great, though!

Their pizza was absolutely one of a kind amazing! Today was our first time ordering and I would definitely recommend the house pizza as well as their Brussels sprouts!

Excellent food. Unlike you will find at any other Italian restaurant. Not that they are bad but the recipes at Carfagnias are unique.

Absolutely authentic experience. There is so much joy fixed into this food. If you're having a bad day, have a bite of something from this place. Great food. Great service.

Sorry just average food and service overall, the pizza was the best thing we ordered.
Small portions for the price.

Delicious food! Their sauces are fantastic, the pizza is phenomenal (must try the sausage).
For some authentic Italian you have to try this place and you won’t be disappointed!

Food is great, but our order is rarely completely right! It's frustrating.last time their phones weren't working so I couldn't call and get a credit, so doubly frustrating!

2nd time here, great family owned recipes with family recipes, super friendly staff & food is excellent

The wedding soup is amazing. When I saw it I wasn't sure if I would like it. One taste and I have found a new favorite. Servers were a bit chaotic reaching in front of others to pass food while helping our server. We will go back

Carfagnas is always a quality meal. You can taste the homemade taste in every meal. Desserts are awesome.

Absolutely delicious. Friendly to both vegetarians and meat eaters. Also kid friendly menu. Fair pricing and excellent wine list. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Large portion sizes and the most amazing chocolate cake. Be prepared to take home leftovers.

Good food and good service. I had Rigatelli pasta. Sauce was good and pasta had good vodka sauce. Their bread was fresh

Really good homemade italian food. Service was excellent! I live 1 1/2 hrs away and will come back every time I'm near Polaris.

Good pizza and good rolls, and you can draw on the tables! Plus, pizza is just good all the time, so they made a good choice making a pizza place.

Excellent Italian food for a reasonable price. The server did a very good job making sure I was satisfied with my food and dining experience.

Great fresh made pasta! I got the eggplant parmesan portions are large! Service was fast and great. First time visit and would return again and again when we are in the area

My steak sandwich was very good. My wife's stromboli was raw on the inside. Side dishes are ala cart and a hair over priced. Service was truly was excellent though.

Restaurant looked very nice but the food was bland and had too much sauce. I think they rely on the business crowd staying at the multitude of hotels nearby who don't know any better for mixh of their business.

The food is always amazing from this place, no complaints there. Totally disappointed with DoorDash though! Worst service ever! Placed an order at 12: 40 for a sandwich and spaghetti, due to be delivered at 1: 37pm. It is now after 2: 30pm and no food. Unable to make contact with Carfagnas (they must be having issues with their phone). No one to contact with door dash. No phone calls received regarding any issues. Totally unacceptable and I will never use Door Dash again for any delivery!

We were very pleased with the service and quality of the food. They have large portions so be ready to take some home. We had a large party of 11 and they were able to serve us efficiently and accurately. I highly recommend Carfagna's.