Cicis Pizza, Fairfield OH

Pizza is ok. Been here twice now. First time in April, no complaints. Hot, fresh, and they kept the buffet stocked. Second time around, not so positive. We went at 1pm on a Sunday, the place was dead. The workers were standing on their phones, and I'm convinced they fed us pizzas from the day before. The only good pizza I had was the Mac and cheese pizza I requested. Everything else was old, and gross. First time five stars, second time, 2 stars. Go to Skyline chili across the street. But you get what you pay for.

Clean, food was nice and hot, pasta was fresh, salad was very crispy and fresh,
And they have a small game room for the kids, GREAT PRICE, THE PRICE IS CHEAPER THAN. CHUCKY CHEESE.

Food quality is hit or miss. Sometimes everything is nice and hot and fresh, and the staff will be fairly friendly, other times the food looks like it has been sitting for a while and the staff is ehhh. Overall, I feel like this location isn't bad but we have ate at one in Gatlinburg and it was sooo much better of an experience, in every way.

For what it is, it's pretty good. Foods always been fresh and hot. It's not gourmet but it's fun for the kids

Excellent food. Ate a variety of choices, all well above expectations
Cici you again soon:)

I'm finally getting around to writing this out.

This Cici's is a staple for me.

I've gone back and forth on their pricing for a little while, but I've come to the conclusion that the pricing is fair. (At this time of my editing this review, September of 2023, that price is about 10.99 for an adult buffet)

Staff is friendly, but aside from interacting at the front cash register, you don't hear much from them.

The music is unobtrusive, the TVs add a little dose of extra stimulation if you want it, and the environment is always, always clean.

It's not authentic Italian pizza, but I like it.

Food was ok, but I had a coupon for 4.99, but was still charged 6.99 for some reason. The people go here are just gross. Coughing on the food and so many other things. My last time there.

The people cooking were very quick and consistent with replacing empty pans and rotating different kinds of items. I'm knocking off a star because the walkway by the seating is so slim and there are always children playing in the middle of it

I edited the review I left 4 years ago, giving them 5 stars for their cheap and decent pizza. Because I will not return here after being a long time customer. Today I presented a coupon for a current promotion they have going. The manager would not honor the coupon. And would not give a reason why. I will not be back.

This is such an amazing CiCi's location! Very positive atmosphere, clean tables, friendly staff who actually care, hard workers that do everything to keep the place running great. All of that seems hard to come by these days. Love the passion they put into making a good experience for everyone.

Inexpensive pizza

Edit: Since my last review, I took away 2 stars. They nearly doubled the price for the buffet, and they require you to get a combo now, even if you just want a water to drink. None of the pizzas taste like they used to. The ranch tastes differently. All and all, I’m going to stop coming back here. The price doesn’t come close to justifying the quality that you receive.

I have ate there twice and every time I have gotten food poisoning everything is dirty bathrooms are gross and they need to be shut down the employees are rude and they don't care about their job things need to change

Cici's is the best pizza buffet I've ever tried, they also have a way to prepare your own salad using only the vegetables that you like, they also have pasta and delicious cinnamon rolls and chocolate brownies for dessert and everything is freshly made and if there is no style of pizza available, you can ask for it and they will make it for you
Besides that it is always clean and its staff is very friendly and all for a reasonable price.

The food isn't bad, but that little weasel Colby Schroeder likes to order water and fill it with soda when the employees aren't looking. What a cheapskate, thief

It is good for fast cheap pizza. The salad bar was fresh and the staff was nice. It's not gourmet it's just cheap eadable food.