Creno's Pizza, Buckeye Lake OH

I was going to complain that my bread was not toasted to my liking but Then I took a bite! Oh my goodness, happiness in my mouth!
Thank you for a delightful experience.

Creno's is consistent. If you have had their pizza and like it, it will be great no matter where you go. I went to this location to pick up pizza for coworkers. It was fun to share a hometown favorite and I was glad it didn't disappoint.

Delicious and hot out of the oven. Im not usually a crust kinda gal, but this was chewy & good!

The Best Pizza Place For Me In Buckeye Lake! Great Staff As Well. They Are Always Cheerful And Accomponing!

Every time I order from here I pay $10 or more for ONE sub. I ask for extras they give me less than what a normal order should be. Today I ordered a Pizza Sub. It was absolutely disgusting. It has barely any toppings on it & once again cost over $10. I pay $0.69 for extra items to not EVER get them. I have been a customer for many years & today will be the last day I ever order from this place! Their wings are never crispy & are very tiny for the price. We don't have many options in this town & I'd rather never eat pizza again before I would ever order from here!

My order below. You can clearly see in the photo that it is not what I paid for AGAIN AND AGAIN! We need a PAPA JOHNS TO DELIVER OUT HERE!

Large Pizza Sub
Mushrooms x2, Cheese x2, Pepperoni, NO Onions, Banana Peppers, Pizza Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Black Olives, Pizza Sauce on the Side
Comments: Side of pizza sauce and the sauce that comes on it $10.32

Buckeye lake location, this used to be my favorite pizza, I don't know what happened but it was worse than any frozen pizza you could buy, crust super thin, barely any sauce and a sprinkling of cheese, felt like the box was empty, worst waste of 15.00 ever spent, sadly I won't be back

First time that we've ordered from Creno's pizza @ Buckeye Lake. We enjoyed everything that we ordered. We'll be going back again.

I am in shock that anyone would hire someone like the women I dealt with tonight. I tried calling 44 times to cancel my oder and when I finally got through she told me it was almost out of the oven so I was getting charged regardless. What kind of owner or manager would hire someone like this. I have never in my 15 years of going to crenos been treated this way or told oh well iam paying anyway. Good food really bad customer service. Awful.

Update sep 13. Come to find out this was a manager that took my oder and she apologized for the way she acted and said that the charge was canceled. But I still will never eat here again.as a manager your expected to be able to be polite regardless if you can't do it let someone else.

This was really good pizza. Thin and not greasy, real mushrooms, my whole family loved it.

Great service. Orders are always correct and on time. Delivery drivers have always been friendly. Been a long time customer and will continue to be.

Amazing service with pick up and delivery because of done both now. My son loves their personal pepperoni pizzas and their boneless chicken wings. I love their salads and they have a really good veggie sub that's filled with veggies and the bread is amazing, I can tell it's homemade. Ever since I moved to Buckeye Lake I'm always looking for the best places to eat at the best prices and here is one of them.

Have never had the pizza but the breadsticks and subs are way better than any other pizza place around here!

No stars for these ingreats. I'm a truck driver. Needed to get some food deliverd to the rest area less than 2 miles away. I was willing to prepay with my credit card, no problem. Nope.we don't go to the rest area"
Screw you! If it was not for truck drivers honey, you would be out of a job! Thanks for nothing!

Placed an online order for delivery today 10/23/20 receipt stated it would be delivered by 2: 56pm. I call the store at 3: 06pm making sure all is ok.

Miss their pizza. Haven't found anything like them here in AZ. Can't wait to get this pizza when I come back for a visit.

Whoever answers the phone is beyond rude everytime we call. I was calling to place an order and asking questions and it seemed like it was an inconvenience to answer.

Called for delivery. Delivery driver shows up at a business where it is posted on the door must have a mask. Driver did not have one on. When asked he laughed. Person that answers the phone is less than friendly. Can’t even pick up in your store so why can drivers deliver without wearing there mask?