D'Amico's Pizzeria, Eastlake OH

Excellent, all around. Nice little area to sit down and eat, if you choose. The service was great, both times we've ordered. The food is excellent and you can't beat the prices! I ordered a hot sub and some fries, and my husband got a calzone. We will definitely be ordering again soon!

I don't normally leave a review, but this place is ok I just wish that they would actually read what the customer asks for when we place a order. I normally order pizza, salad, cheese stick and garlic butter on the side. I like my pizza hot not cold and doughy and be light with the sauce my pizza is always Luke warm and smothered in sauce. As for the cheese sticks they have no flavor at all. Salads looks 3 day old. And the garlic butter is margarine and garlic powder. Im part Italian so this is a huge disappointment for me when it to ordering pizza from. Here. I want to like this place but every time I order from here I get nothing but cold food.

Most sloppy pizza I have ever ordered overly greasy won't ever order from here again. I couldnt even pick up a piece without all the topping falling off.if I wanted to eat with a fork I would of ordered a salad

Let me start with I don't normally do bad reviews. If I were able to give no stars I would. Ordered a small pizza 15 minutes after they opened and gave them half an hour before going in. It wasn't ready. I was told 5 more minutes and 20 minutes later I had to ask about it AGAIN only to be told 5 more minutes. Two people ordered (1 was a pizza) after the I arrived and got their food before mine was ready. When the "manager" came out he was incredibly rude. His response was "well that's just the way it is! " Well I will NEVER go there again and that's just the way it is!

First time to D'Amico's. Pizza was pretty standard but good. I got the veggie pizza and it wasn't wet, even with tomatoes and mushrooms which can get kind of soggy. I also got the eggplant app.it had to have been a mistake.it was salty enough to make you pucker and your throat tighten. I'm guessing they heavily salted the eggplant and forgot to rinse it or wipe off the excess. I tried the other ones in the batch and they were all similar. When I paid, the counter is too wide, so the kid threw my credit card at me lol. Definitely caught me off guard.
If I try it again, I'll update! I went because it's a local place with good reviews so maybe I caught them on an "off day. "

I’ve always enjoyed the food - pizza is awesome but most don’t know they have the best burger in town!

My last name is Irish but I’m 100% Italian and this is the most authentic Italian Pizza around! We love the pepperoni pizza! The sauce is just right, not sweet like Non-authentic sauce, there’s plenty of pepperoni and the crust is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. I never ordered from any where else after the first time we tried it. Thank you!

Best pizza this side of town. Nobody else comes close. The sauce is the best. Home made? Don't know but it is consistently the best. Home deliveries always on time. Rate #1

Seriously, the best pizza on the Eastside.

Everything appears to be made from scratch or bought fresh. Tastes amazing. The sauce is great and so is the dough/crust. They don't try to fit a certain style like NY or Detroit style - it's just great pizza all around.

The pepperoni? Cut to order off a quality pepperoni roll. The sausage? Made in store and portioned fresh onto each pizza.

The calzones are amazing too. Looking forward to trying more of the menu.

Oh, and they are a family owned on-of-a-kind pizza shop.

Good wings, hearty pizza.cooked correctly.crispy/crunchy where it should be, soft/juicy where it should be. 5-stars.veggies tasted fresh.after taking a look at some reviews here - seems to me that they've corrected whatever issues the Karen's were complaining about.

All I got to say is: Good pizza and wings.
(im two orders deep)

Pro tip:
pre-tipping 20-30% boosts food quality everywhere in the world. (trust me, I worked food service delivery in high school)

A meditation:
I'm a peasant not a king - anyone who brings me food deserves at minimum $10-20 tip. The world would be a better place if everyone had that attitude. Grease those palms. (That's how the real world works)

five-star service starts with the customer.just look at that pizza?
it tastes as good as it looks.

Burger and fries were really good. Wings I asked for well done and they definitely were not all the sauce was kind of at the bottom. Pizza was decent nothing special.

Hands down the best pizza and calzones in the area! Recommend that anyone who is wanting pizza for dinner, order from here, no regrets ever.

Ordered delivery tonight and they brought me a crushed, unedible pizza. Disappointing! Obviously something was sitting on top of the box.

Online order and delivery. Delivered when quoted. Hot, fresh and delicious. I order from here about once a week or so. Never had a bad experience.

Love it there. Their white pizza is the best by far anywhere around here and I’ve tried them all. This place hands down

Used to be good Pizza but more recently last 2 times I’ve ordered an extra large pizza it’s been over cooked and tastes like greasy cheese on cardboard with hardly any toppings probably won’t be ordering again. Would like to add it Looks like a puddle of puke on a a slightly overcooked pizza crust when opened.

Pizza was soaked in grease. Use to enjoy their pizza think I've bought my last from here

We had pIzza (half cheese, half pep, sausage and banana peppers - really good. Wings were a little disappointing (asked for crispy and they were average). Excellent calzone!

Food is very Good and reasonably priced. I love they do delivery.no grub hub OR door dash.how refreshing! WELL DONE!