Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR, Cincinnati OH

Love Goodfella’s. One of my favorite pizza joints. They have a great bar upstairs as well, a good place to hang out for a drink.

The white pizza and bourbon selection are unparalleled, and Tom the bartender made us a couple of their specialty cocktails that were delicious!

Great pizza made with flare and with very personable staff. The drinks were good this time. The new bar staff is still learning the cocktails lots of recipe peeking but great ideas and friendly folks. Keep it up.

Called and asked for call ahead seating and she said there was not, which wasn’t a problem. I asked what the wait time might be because I was a little far from the place & she said “well there’s a line”…

I had to leave stars but I never actually got to eat the food because I placed an order online when everything said they were open but they weren’t yet their online ordering system accepted my payment and told me my order would be ready the next day. Nowhere online or in their ordering system did it say that they were closed. I am guessing the pizza is great however I just spent 55 dollars on nothing: (Now I can’t even cancel my order: (

Goodfellas has great tasting pizza. The staff was super friendly and patient, even with my toddler grandson running around. We had a great time.

Super good calzone. Good beer selection, and great whiskey selection. Only bad thing was waiting 10 minutes or so for anyone to say hi. Waited around looking completely lost and staff was too busy stocking and cleaning the bar. Not a bad thing, but a quicker acknowledgement would have been much appreciated.

I really enjoyed the slice of artichoke pizza I had, and the location with the bar upstairs was pretty sweet. It's definitely got a great thing going as a hangout spot, and it was clearly popular. The New York-style pizza was fairly priced and tasty, and the workers seemed pretty cheerful.

The security staff does not know what they’re doing. People getting enraged just trying to buy pizza on a Saturday night dealing with the poorly managed lines.

Goodfellas has great pizza, some of the best pizza I have had. The staff are super friendly and the restaurant itself has an incredibly welcoming atmosphere.

Best pizza I've had in a long time loved the upstairs seating
Unfortunately I was only visiting city. Wish there was one in NH

We went here and the pizza was amazing, very good New York style foldable crust with a nice crunch and staff was great. 5 stars, setting was terrific also. I will go back again and it's gonna be recommend for friends and family.

Great atmosphere, great food and great drinks. Nice laid back environment and a sweet patio that encourages you to meet the people around you. Glad we visited on our trip to Cincinnati, we were not disappointed.

This was our first time eating at Goodfella’s and it was not disappointing. Brandon recommended the white pizza and it was delicious. The medium size was huge and the pizza was fresh. Brandon also told us about a location that just opened near us in Chattanooga Tennessee that we are looking forward to visiting soon.

This place is hands down some of the best pizza in town and the enviroment is super cool. Pizza is huge and the crust slapped. Service was great and super friendly, one of the managers chatted with me and the boys for a bit since they were from outta town and I really didnt want to explain all places to check out to them. Pointed out some spots to hit afterwards. They knew what was up (Im from cinci but buddies werent). I cant wait to go back and bring my daughter and my family. Will be going back. If i could give 6 stars I would! Keep it up yall cause its fantastic! Will be recommending.

Best pizza in the entire city and they have the most hard-working and amazing staff around. With everything going on with staffing shortages, the managers are there every day working super hard to make sure their customers are taken care of. Everyone that works there deserves a massive raise for everything they have put up with through Covid and everything else going on right now.

Also their cannoli's are amazing.