Hindsight Pizza Kitchen Wings Up!, Toledo OH

Love coming into this spot. Great food to share amongst friends and family.

Can’t wait until I’m back home to take my family!

Overall, food was decent. I got large cheese pizza, Italian cheese bread w/marinara and garlic sauce. Pizza, cheese bread and even marinara dipping sauce was drenched in Italian seasoning. Almost overwhelmingly. Garlic sauce was very watery and bland. Marinara sauce was too chunky and very sour tasting. The cook on both were very good. Cheese was cheesy. Just wish the seasonings weren’t so over powering that the food tasted all the same.

Amazing pizza. Some of the best in Toledo with a really good variety of options. Will be back.

Hindsight pizza is Delicious! They have some of the best pizza! I highly recommend the Korean Chicken and Loaded Potato Pizza.

I tried a simple pepperoni and bacon and had the crust Hinds way and it was phenomenal! Best pizza I have had in a long time. I will definitely be ordering again real soon!

Ordered here for the first time tonight after hearing all the good reviews. Not sure if we came on a bad night but the pizza was terrible. Very greasy to the point that it leaked all over my counter from the box. The cheese bread was decent but felt that was a little greasy as well. Also the marinera sauce for the bread I think was salsa. Really not sure what all the hype is about as I have had way better expierience at my local marcos pizza. All in all I'd give the pizza a 4.6/10 and would not recommend it.

Best pizza and service by far! Chris and the employees were so nice and professional! Definitely telling everyone about this place!

Chris, the owner, is outstanding! Excellent customer service and catered to our every need for my sons birthday party. Everyone was raving about the pizzas! We had a huge order and Chris personally delivered to the party. The pizzas and cheese bread came hot and fresh out of the oven! 10/10 will recommend to everyone!

The Korean BBQ pizza was a huge hit when we ordered take out for a small get together! Delicious!

We order pizza every Sunday at our house. We’ve ordered “Hindsight Pizza Kitchen” 3 Sundays in a row…. That’s a big deal. Try it

Hindsight is the hottest new pizza place! The food always looks exactly like the pictures in the menu. I love that there is so many different specialty pizzas! The ‘Korean chicken’ and ‘Jalapeño Popper’ are my absolute faves! If you have not yet tried, you’re missing out!

Having a dairy allergy, it’s hard to find options to enjoy. I tried Hindsight pizza with the vegan cheese and I will definitely be going back to get it again! It satisfied all the cravings and will be ordering again!

I have ordered from Hindsight Pizza Kitchen several times since they opened. I have tried different items from pizza to subs to breadsticks to dessert and have not been disappointed at all. I even had it for a work lunch and everyone enjoyed it. I highly recommend and will continue to support this business. Try the Korean Chicken pizza! Delicious!

This jalapeño popper pizza is amazing! The wings and everything I've had from here is top notch! Very creative specials! Everyone should try the loaded potato pizza.

This will be my 3rd time ordering Hindsight Pizza. I ordered 2 16” traditional round specialty pizzas both Hinds way! The Korean chicken which happens to be my personal favorite! Also order this months speciality pizza the Loaded Potato. Both of these pizzas were absolutely delicious. I will say the loaded potato is definitely loaded, I wish I would’ve went thin crust on that one. I am going to have to try that for next time. The staff greeted me as I walked through the door and were very attentive to my needs, and answering any questions what so ever. Also this has become my favorite pizza joint and I enjoy it even more knowing it’s a local place. It is a 20 minute drive for me to go pick up, although some might say that is too far. I’m willing to drive this far for an amazing pie and, variety of items that they offer. Keep up the great work and can’t wait to come back!

I have ordered from hindsight twice now and both experiences have been great! It was fast and the pizza was amazing! Will definitely be ordering again soon!

Outstanding pizza! Dare I say, gourmet!? Their customer service is great. I picked our order up and the cleanliness inside the store was on point which is always refreshing to see. I’m a hard guy to please and my experience with Hindsight Pizza Kitchen surpassed all expectations. Well done!

We ordered a deep dish pizza and a loaded dough pizza and WOW! The sauce is sweet and the pizza is anything but greasy! We will definitely order again and now they deliver in our area…. Bonus!