Jenny's Homemade Cookies, Cincinnati OH

Order ahead to guarantee your favorites. This is a small family owned bakery next to Bridgetown Finer Meats. The cookies are to die for with seasonal favorites like Santa Claus and Christmas tree iced Minnies. It has a small seating area to enjoy cookies with hot tea or bottled soft drinks. Cookies are priced at $4-5 dollars each.

They are the best cookies I’ve ever had, better than crumbl cookies. But they are wayyy too expensive. No matter how good the cookies are, I can’t justify myself to spend $4 on one cookie. I could get a whole meal from McDonald’s for cheaper than the price of one cookie.
So I treat them as a luxury treat, something I’ll get on special occasions every once in a while like for a birthday or a holiday. Not something I can afford to buy very often. It’s too bad because I really do enjoy these cookies. I think $2 a cookie would be a much more reasonable price and more people would probably buy their cookies at that price. They’d probably get more business and make more profit that way by selling more rather than focusing on making more profit per cookie.

My fiance loves cookie cakes for his birthday and sure, I could have gotten a roll of dough and done it myself but would it have been incredible? No. I strive to provide those I love with above and beyond incredible experiences always. I found Jenny’s with a quick Google search. I wasn’t about to buy a mall cookie cake.

Jenny was prompt and quickly replied to my emails and we discussed on the phone what I wanted. I have a really sensitive stomach, so at pick up, I purchased a white chocolate cranberry cookie (which was amazing) to go with my fiancés cookie cakes to see how this would settle. To my surprise I’ve had no issues and after reading further into these reviews and Jenny’s Homemade Cookies website, it’s really good to know that there are places that don’t skimp on quality ingredients, even if you’re paying a little more.

Remember, quality over quantity. Not to mention the individual cookies are HUGE. They’re definitely worth a couple extra dollars. Trust me, she has a great flavor line up and they are amazing quality baked with a lot of love and it is so evident in her work.

Jenny, the cookie cakes were a hit with my fiance and coworkers, and though this is about 45 minutes away from us, we will definitely be back!

Too pricey but good cookies. $24 for 6 uniced cookies seems way too costly unless they had been exceptional and larger than they were.

Bar none the best cookies in Cincinnati. Forget crumble or any of the other places. When I was serving in the Air Force I would still order and have them shipped and no matter where I went they were an absolute HIT.also incredibly sweet staff and did I mention the cookies are incredible?

These cookies just might be my favorite cookies of ALL TIME. My favorite is the Smores and regular chocolate chip. They're salty, which I LOVE. You can taste the real ingredients in every bite. 10/10 would recommend Jenny's! Staff is always friendly and inviting.

The salted caramel dark chocolate chip cookies are so good! The store is cute and the cookies are very tasty.

After having a sample of a chocolate chip cookie, I drove over an hour for these cookies and they are worth the drive. BEST CC Cookie Ive ever had and Ive had a lot