Mehaffies Pies, Dayton OH

They sell soooo many different pies, also serve cheesecake, pumpkin rolls, brownies, also pie and cheesecake slices.

All of their sweettreats are delicious, this business is a staple in the dayton area.

It has been forever since I stopped in here the clerk was real friendly and helpful everything is always top notch

Amazing strawberry pie if you can get there during the work day. I suggest they stay open until at least 6pm so the worker bees have time to stop in.

Long, long standing local Pie baker.any pie you want is possible, any way you want.sugar-free, etc. 10 or more kinds always available, any quantity by order.always good!

Very friendly staff knowledgeable about their products. Delicious pies fairly priced I will be back again for sure.

Love their pies butterscotch strawberry rhubarb chocolate peanut butter especially the little round table that has pies that they made too many good deals

I am beyond happy I found this little treasure. All sorts of delicious pies, at a decent price! The building is clean, the customer service was exceptional, and I will definitely be going back!

Guys please do your self a favor and get the cheese cake or anything from here and you will go back no bs this place is crazy good

Peanut butter pie with meringue. Best option ever.

Friendly folks. Fast service.
No complaints!

Love this place, always watch for fresh strawberry pies in February. Customer service is always 10/10.

Good pies. Good selection. Personal service. Lots of parking at the door. Generous business hours. Occasional discounted "baked too many pies" table in the store.

Let me start by stating this “ if you haven’t had their pie then stop whatever it is your doing and go have one”! My husband and I drive about a 2hr round trip to buy pies from Mehaffies because they are indeed the best! We also can buy them from a meat market closer to us but if we don’t put in a special order they might not have the ones we want!

The staff is so kind and patient! The pies are so good! I highly recommend the banana cream pie!

If you are looking for fantastic pies of all kinds, Mehaffies Pies in Dayton, Ohio should be where you go! My favorites are strawberry, banana cream and pumpkin. I wish I could eat them a lot more often, but I can't. They also have cheesecake, whipped cream and other accessories we need with our pies! Enjoy everyone!

This is the BEST dessert spot in Dayton! These are not grocery store pies! Huge selection! Buy two! That way you don't have to share!

Very friendly service and omgosh, amazing varieties of delicious pies.you name it, they make it. I highly recommend

Close to home. The best pies in the world along with good prices. Quick and accurate service. Friendly and enthusiastic staff.

Best pies for your taste buds. Wide selection to choose from. Nothing beats the strength of experience. Just look at the years they've been in business. That alone speaks for itself.

Pies were excellent. Apple and Sugar creme. Service was friendly and quick. Definitely will consider for the holidays. Pies tasted homemade. Very pleased with the overall experience. Will be back again and recommend to friends and family.