Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co., Worthington OH

Consistently provides the best cookies, pies, cinnamon rolls etc.that keep me coming back!

Today was our first time going into Mrs. Goodman’s and it was the most amazing experience. It smelled wonderful. The young lady who helped us was amazing. We cannot wait to come back!

As usual the cake was delicious! But who knew cookies made to look like peas could be so adorable! Thank you so much for doing again what you do so well!

Great selection of bakery items! Wish the hours were just a bit longer so we could visit after school. We have really loved the iced cookies and the brownies most of all!

I stopped by for my first visit today to get goodies for work. Not only is the store welcoming and bright when you walk in, but it smells amazing. The ladies working were so nice as well.
The items I purchased have been raved over at work.
I will definitely be back to visit again soon.

Loved the strawberry, kemon and orange cupcakes.
However had to wait a while before someone helped and I was the only one in the store. There was one person on the phone and several.others inside who kept watching but never came out to take the order. The 3 stars is because of this.

I had high hopes from the great reviews but was disappointed. I had a strawberry cupcake that was semi frozen and didn't taste fresh. My grandson got a wedge of cake that he liked.

It is easy to make a cake that tastes good. The place where most people fail (from a taste perspective) is the frosting. I often skip the cake at a wedding because they are just not worth the calories. I usually bake my own cakes, but, when I am too busy, or if the cake is too much for my home kitchen, I fall back to Mrs. Goodman's since it is a cake worth eating on all accounts.

I have used Mrs. Goodman's numerous times for many years and I have always been very happy with the results.

I have purchased cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. I needed Christmas cookies for work, so I put in an order for a few dozen; yummy.

They have gluten free cupcakes in the freezer. I like to stop on and get some for the family and I get regular cookies for myself.

Did I mention that you can get oatmeal cookies with butterscotch. One of the few places I like the chocolate chip cookies.

Absolutely amazing red velvet cake. Not only was it beautifully decorated, it was delicious! The cake was perfectly moist, not dry at all like some red velvet cales can be. The frosting was sweet and cream cheesy, not overly sweet. We will 100% be ordering from Mrs. Goodman's in the future. We can't wait to try the other goodies in the shop as well.

Absolutely 100% delicious what a hidden gem. EVERYTHING there is to die for delicious. Homemade truly artist in all the do Pies, Cakes, Cookies scones you name it. If you haven't tried them make it a point to do so you will not be disappointed.

Came to visit Columbus from Akron for a birthday celebration and ordered a cake from Mrs. Goodman's. The cake I ordered was delightful! I will order again in the future! Thank you for such a GREAT CAKE! GOOD CUSTOMER SERVICE AS WELL!

First time trying this place - I got a delicious key lime pie as a gift. I would definitely recommend! I’ll be back myself.

Everything here is delicious. Cakes are beautiful. I learned on my last visit that if they are out of scones for the day you can still buy frozen ones for take and bake. They were just as amazing and now I can keep some on hand in my freezer (for those scone emergencies). By far my favorite bakery in the Columbus area.

We ordered a cake to celebrate my nephews 3rd birthday and after talking about his love for dinosaurs during the order, Mrs. Goodman’s bakery was so gracious to surprise us with an amazing dinosaur cake for his birthday! Not only was the cake design amazing, it was also delicious and perfect to help us celebrate his birthday! We will definitely be using Mrs. Goodmans again in the future and highly recommend!