Papa Nick's Pizza & Pasta, Cleveland OH

Ordered a pizza yesterday from here for the first time the Pizza was absolutely incredible!

Literally just paid 13 dollars for ham on bread.
No mayo, no lettuce, no tomato. Never again.

First-time customer, I ordered for delivery online, the Chicken Wedges Basket, and a slice of pizza. I received a call and was told that the pizza slice was no longer an option on the menu, he just wanted me to know. That happens, no big deal, but instead of leaving it at that, I was told they would be sending me a small pepperoni pizza for the price of the slice! I actually ordered the slice because I wasn't in the mood for a whole pie and I wanted to try their pizza, and I'm telling you, I will never order a pizza from anywhere else! Thank you Phil!

Perfect pizza. Lots of crispy salty pros, perfect balance of cheese and sauce, and a delicious crust. I ordered the pan style pizza with red sauce and double pepperoni! Yummy

I ordered pizza and salad for my office staff. It was awesome! Papa Nick's Pizza and Pasta has been around for a long time and they never disappoint. It is tried and true!

Was left on hold for 10 minutes then picked up pizza wasn't even xl but placed in xl box and pizza was having tops sliding off.not happy with this service this time we always loved this pizza

Craving-satisfying pizza! Wonderful owner.
Definitely worth picking up a slice here!

Ordered 2 pepperoni and sausage pizza and two dozens of wings, Spent $72 bucks. The wings were ok, the pizza was really dry there was barely any sauce on the pizza. All though the flavor on the pizza was really good the pies need more sauce! Drove from Euclid to Lakewood due to the fact I was seeing amazing pictures on Facebook with toppings fallen of pizza I’m highly disappointed ordered pepperoni and sausage there was a lot of pepperoni but barely any sausage. I feel like I was taken. Arcade pizza on Broadway in Cleveland cheaper pizza and much better. Very disappointed in Pappa Nicks after spending $72 hard own dollars.

Papa Nick's was just what we needed! We ordered spaghetti, pizza, wings, and a calzone, all which were very good. The wings are not breaded, and even the "hot" is not super hot. They are huge wings, and were a little on the dry side on the edges, which I really like. The pizza and calzone dough was springy and full of flavor, almost buttery and a little sweet. The spaghetti was nice and they were huge portions. The drinks are done in a cooler inside.you just keep your empties and they add them all up once you are done. We also got to sit outside - they have several places to sit.

Papa Nick (Phil) was a gracious host. Very easy to talk to and even opened a few minutes early! Food is STILL amazing and hopefully Papa Nick will be around another 41 years, slinging pie in the back greeting everyone with a smile.

Not worth going to overpriced and very dry pizza ingredients seem like they are out of a can
Stingy on toppings
Chicken tenders had more breading than chicken seemed undercooked

The gentleman whippin in the kitchen has been making pan in pizza’s for 42 years! This pizza here has crispy crust on the bottom and plus on top! The pepperoni was just to the point of sears crisp packed full of flavor and sauce that complimented the cheese to creamy perfection! It was an absolute mouth watering experience! They offer Pino Grigio that pairs exceptionally well with any combination of meals they offer!

My daughter said this was One of thee best pizzas she's had in a while. Perfectly made.

Food is consistent and above average. Been coming here for decades.
Can't beat their marinara sauce! Nancy Vaughan

I’m not one to knock a local business. Completely against what I stand for. But I ordered a margarita pizza and this is what I got. I can understand mistaking one item but in addition I ordered and Italian sub with meat and cheese only. You guessed it lol it had More than meat and cheese.