Play It Again Sports, North Olmsted OH

Picked over, prices are like that of new items, trade ins are like Gamestop. They will give you $5 and resell for $50. Just not worth the effort to save a nominal amount.

This place is okay and they have a lot of nice things and most are gently used. The prices are still a little too high for my blood, but you probably will find what you are looking for here. The staff is helpful and knowledgeable, but I feel you can do the same thing while going online.

High prices when it comes to dumbbells. Bought a single 40 pound weight for $87. Substantially less everywhere else I looked after the fact.

Any chance of ever getting a call back or are you guys just gonna keep my $30? Can’t wait to hear the explanation on this one!

Because you took the time to call me shows you are professional…. I appreciate you and your staff Dan. We’ll get it all straightened out tomorrow.

Purchased several golf clubs off their website. Cancels order with no explanation. Great business plan, buy peoples junk and mark it up 4 times what you paid them for it. Just sell your stuff on facebook marketplace people.

I wish I could give 4 & 1/2 stars. That would be more accurate. The sales person I dealt with was very helpful and knowledgeable. I simply needed an inexpensive used baseball glove for my 6 year old boy to play in his rec league and a bat. As any sales person is going to do, they tried to initially sell me a used but almost new glove. Unfortunately, that one was priced the exact same as a new glove. (I had one waiting in my online Target cart, so I knew for sure the price). HOWEVER, when I explained that I was looking for a cheap glove that would still work well (my son keeps loosing his gloves) they actively helped me find a glove that would work, fit, and meet my price requirements.
They did not have any used bats in the size my son needed and they were selling new bats for 50.00 to 70.00. They were honest about not having used bats available. Summary: know the prices for new equalivant items before you go. They are still VERY helpful. Be an informed shopper and you will have a pretty good chance of walking away satisfied.

Store needs to get organized. Customers would buy more if it was easier to find. Have a blowout sale for one week. They make it friendly to shop.

Other than maybe happening to find what I'm looking for. I couldn't imagine having a great time at Play It Again Sports.

Normally I like this place and it's a pretty good concept. Today my wife went in for weights and the guy working there acted like it personally offended him when she asked if they had them and didnt. "Oh I guess we dont have what you want, do we now? I guess you'll just have to go some where else" that was her only interaction with them. Her not buying weights isnt affecting his paycheck.

Excellent store well suited and respectfully taking advantage of the opportunity thr pandemic has presented them. Their prices remain fair.

They have a large volume of products with prices that are unbeatable! You have to understand most products are used and you have to be willing to look through the large quantities that are there.

Absolutely love this place! They pay really good money and used sporting goods. Also they have a very friendly and helpful staff

Great place for cheap sporting equipment. A large selection of golf and baseball/softball stuff. Found a jr driver for my daughter for under 8 bucks.

Small shop with a great selection of used sports gear, but at times things look a bit picked over and disorganized.

I've never bought new equipment there because the selection and pricing isn't as great as other sporting goods stores. Obviously, their competitive differentiator is used gear, and I've saved hundreds there over the years.

If you want to sell them your used gear, expect to get 20% - 30% of it's retail value depending on condition, demand, etc. Not great, but they're in business to make money, and it's better than your old gear sitting around and collecting dust.

Store is packed barely any room anywhere and be careful what you buy. Might be able to find it cheaper or close to price brand new

This is a no frills used/some new sporting equipment store and they move a lot of product. If you are looking for discount golfing, skiing, work out equipment and clothing and more, and you are in the area, check them out.

Amazing service, answered question over the phone, helped me look through a huge selection of ski boots, and pick out just the right ones for my son! Save me a ton of time, and was friendly throughout. GREAT SERVICE!

Play it again has so many deals on their new and gently used items. I highly recommend using them for your league uniforms and gear.

I bought ski boots here one year ago 2 set for 150.00. I took them there today along with 2 set of skis and poles they offer me 6 dollars what a gimmick

Play it again sells and buys gently used sporting equipment. I think it's a franchise, so each location may be run by different owners/managers. I prefer the location in North Olmsted because of selection and price. The stores are generally clean, and the young staff has been consistently friendly and helpful. The prices are fair. The selection is good, but you may want to call ahead for specialty items or at change of seasons. It's especially good for expensive items, such as snow skiing, for kids who are growing and need bigger boots, poles, and skis for example. The have pretty much every major sport as well as exercise equipment. Try play it again before you pay full retail. I haven't had any problems with anything we purchased there.