Potbelly Sandwich Shop, Dublin OH

The Hickman concrete crew loves your subs so much, they have had me get them belly boxes 3 times already since Friday! Excellent food, service and prices for the belly boxes are perfect!

Staff was nice. Broccoli cheddar soup was pretty good. Sandwich was was not so great.

I got a small BLTA, I knew it didn't come with cheese, but I forgot to add it so when my sandwich was toasted the edges of the bacon and bread came out burnt.

I definitely gotta remember to add cheese if I go back.

Went here for the very first time and was not disappointed at all! I did an online order and since this was my first time I was not aware of how the pick-up was. The gentleman working were very nice and respectful and showed me exactly where to pick up my food (by the door) the food was absolutely delicious and the sub looked just how it did online.my food was still hot on my 15 minute drive home! The resturant was very clean! And they helped me right away! The gentleman at the front counter was even talking to my toddler! It was very sweet! 10/10 recommend!

Very filling and flavorful. Getting to the place was a bit of a hassle, hedges could use a trim.

I’m not sure where the pics on the website are from of the sandwiches but they definitely are not the ones you get when you order. Pitiful amount of meat on the sub your better off getting a gas station sub! I was excited to try this place and now I’m highly disappointed. $10 for four pieces of lunch meat on an ok bun. And that’s a regular not a small! This place is a huge ripoff!

Love this location most of the time but sometimes they deny me extra crackers for my bowl of soup. If I could pay for extra I definitely would but that isn't an option, but never expected to be told no I guess? Maybe I'll just have to keep some crackers in my car?

Excellent food, great customer service, helped turn a bad evening around for me. You guys made a regular customer tonight- thank you

I was there yesterday and the service was very friendly and fast! So I went back today and had the same great service. Highly recommend!

I have never experienced anything like this. I could smell something weird when I opened the bag; and, then I took a bite and it was awful. I think the lettuce was bad. I couldn't eat it at all. And, of course, I paid for avocado, but there was no avocado. The other thing that bothered me was the fact that I ordered online for a specific time. I arrived at that time, and it was not ready. I would have received the sandwich quicker if I just went in and ordered. What's the point of online, if it isn't ready at the time designated?

Sad to see this location continually go downhill. Native Chicagoan so happy when it was in Dublin. Hit or miss on service and taste. And no comment when twice I asked why an employee was not wearing her mask over her nose. Employee said it was too hot the first time and walked away the next time and Manager said nothing. Our last time here!

I am sorry to leave such a negative review but I went here for lunch with my boyfriend and it was the worst meal that I've ever had.
I ordered a pick two, the uptown salad and blta sub. The lettuce in the salad tasted like it was de-thawing. I couldn't even swallow the bread for the sandwich, I took a few bites and had to toss it. The avocado was brown and not fresh. Overall, the quality of ingredients were poor and I could tell they were not properly stored to preserve freshness.

The grilled chicken on flat bread was top grade. My wife at the entire sandwichand loved it. I got the Italian with everything. A bit of heat and delicious is all I can say. Thank you!

Had the half turkey club and half soup. Pretty average food, like the toasted sandwich though. My wife’s salad was not so fresh and the tomato soup was not good. Hadn’t been here in a while and will probably not be back too soon.

Can't stop throwing up. I suspect something was terribly wrong with the strawberry milkshake. I'll post more once I stop retching.

I went here to pick up an order. They had taken a catering order when they couldn’t handle it. I was in there for 15 minutes before they even acknowledged me, and they hadn’t even started the order. They only had 3 people working a busy lunch shift. I definitely won’t be ordering from or eating at this location.