Preteroti's Spaghetti House, Findlay OH

I have brought my son here multiple times. It was very good all other visits. The food, the people, in general a pleasant experience. This last time going on a Wednesday, the normal lady wasn't there. I believe she might be the owner. We were sat in a corner with dirty and duct taped booths. I thought, ok it's because I have a child with me. It went down hill. The service was poor, and the pasta was drown in a watery sauce. I hope this is the exception and not a new standard.

Had the chicken parmesan. Huge portion and it was good
My family had the lasagna which took up the whole plate. They enjoyed it.

Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken just didn't have a good taste. Wife loved the lasagna.

Best food and restaurant! I’ve been going since they have opened and the owners have seen my family grow! They make us feel like family when we come in. Always recommended!

This was our first time at Preteroti's. The staff was fantastic and very friendly and the food was great! Very large portions and very tasty!

I ordered eggplant Parmesan and received a coaster size portion on 3 pounds of spaghetti which was overcooked and gross. I thought these people were Italian! Sad

We had a group of 11 for a get together last evening. First time there for most of them. All were very pleased! Service was awesome, food superb! Definitely be returning, thanks for a great experience!

First time indulging, ordered delivery so I did not have the pleasure to experience the atmosphere and service. However if they are anything like the food, absolute perfection, no complaints. I rated service and atmosphere because I didn't know if it would hurt the overall rating if I didn't

This little Italian restaurant will give all other Italian restaurants a run for their money! They have the most amazing Italian food I have been able to find locally! The service is, unfortunately, slow. They are always busy but the food is worth the wait!

We will not be returning to this restaurant. While the portions are huge, the prices are out of sight. I would expect a much more warm and welcoming, high-end establishment. Instead, I found it to be cold and diner-like.

I've drove past this place many times and debated stopping. Today I was hungry and decided it was time to give it a try. Looking over the menu I opted for Calamari as an appetizer (it was a pretty generous portion and well made too.) I couldn't help but notice the spaghetti and meatballs said homemade and further elaborated that the recipe is a family recipe nearly a century old. The sauce and meatballs both were a knockout. Don't sleep on this place like I had, well worth the stop.

The last few times we've gone in the service hasn't really been there. Tonight we went in at about 8: 00. Our greeting was just"Are you picking up a to-go order? " When I stated that we were eating in, she rolled her eyes. I tried ordering a Coke and was told all they had was water, lemonade, tea, or orange soda. We tried ordering mozzarella sticks and were told they were out. We got our entrees and were told the bread would be right out. We were only given one slice per person (maybe this is a new thing) but we normally get two each. We were left feeling like we were in the way so we took the rest of our food home.

Great food and great people. Well worth our more than two and a half hour round trip to enjoy the amazing food and of course the wonderful people. Micah is wonderful and has been amazing to work with regarding the food for our daughter and future son-in-laws upcoming wedding reception.

My man & I got takeout Friday night and the lady at the window said rudely “no tip? ” while laughing it off. In my 26 years of living I have never experienced that & I was baffled because it was begging behavior while being rude. On top of it, she forgot our plastic wear. There was no need for a tip. The chicken parm & lasagna was good but everything else was not, especially not welcoming for my first time. The garlic bread is not toasted & on the sweeter side. Solid 4/10

Quick, friendly service and server. Good food, especially garlic bread. Huge amount of spaghetti and meatballs for the price. We like that the salad dressing was drizzled over top of the side salad not drenching the salad. I would have liked more spaghetti sauce but it was still tasty. (I saw on the menu that you can order extra sauce for $2.) A very enjoyable experience.

I work for Findlay Recovery Center
Yesterday we played putt putt, arcade games. We like to introduce our clients to new atmospheres sober.
When I called to make a reservation I was elated that they accepted 5 of us a half hour before closing!
The service was impeccable. The food was delicious as I had been telling my party of 5 all afternoon.
Thank you so very much for taking us in on short notice, and bringing so much joy and deliciousness to our table!