Sarah's Pizza, Brookville OH

We had ordered a few hours in advance and requested delivery to a local venue. The delivery driver was respectfully prompt and the food was perfect. Thanks!

Best pizza around! Ordered a large it was huge definitely could feed the whole family with one large pizza

Fabulous pizza & wings! Friendly and was impressed with the legal concealed carry sign too!

Small pizza was delicious and of good value. Would have given five stars except for the unexplained delay in receiving order. 15 minutes promised time turned into 30 minutes, only after questioning 20 minutes in as to where the pizza was. I think I may have been forgotten. I will definitely go back and recommend.

This place is amazing great people that work there. The owner is a great guy. Love home town pizza places

I ordered a pizza and it was NOT good at all to much sauce and not enough of the other items I wanted on my pizza the steak sub I ordered last week was SOO GOOD but the pizza wasn't

I ordered a grilled chicken salad and pizza bread. The salad portion was extremely generous. And the pizza bread was amazing! My new favorite food.

Pizzas were way over cooked, which made them a chewy, awful tasting waste of money. It's very disappointing that they would send out an order in this condition, especially considering the amount of money they charge for their pizzas.

Ordered 2 hours prior to break at work and it was still 10 minutes late. Only have 30 minutes for break to eat so won’t be ordering from them again!

One of Brookville's little secrets. Their marinara is some of the best! I highly recommend the baked spaghetti with meatballs.

What a horrible experience, I ordered a sub with extra meat and Xtra onions, no peppers! And cheese sticks. The meat was frozen in the middle and to top it off they were fake patties, there was no mushrooms or onions on the sub at which I payed extra for extra. When calling to correct matters with management he argued that the s were green, I told him the colour didn't matter I did not order them, he argued that there was plenty of mushrooms and onions. NOT 1 folks! To end with no solution the manager then took and accused me of having a speech impediment by saying I threatened him. Clean out your ears sir or atleast don't try to redeem yourself by correlation of a made up story. So therefore my final conclusion is 0 stars! Not even on the map unless you need a quick fix for your fury family friend, a sort of replacement for Purina or Alpo. Management handled things as if selling 10 cent lemonade. The Holiday Inn express where I am staying said the owner is a known drug addiction and the place use to be great but has taken an unfortunate turn, I'd steer clear.

Horrible experience over the phone the guy was very disrespectful obviously he didn’t want my business. Pizza was very greasy and the wings were not cooked all the way through. I will most definitely stick to the Lewisburg Sarah’s that is way more friendly and the food is way better I would NOT recommend the brookville Sarah’s to anyone. I would give 0 stars to it if I could.

I pay $30 for a pizza! I get short on the toppings, over priced, And they close when we have 1/4 inch of snow

Waited no time to place my order on a Saturday night, ready in 25 mins and was exactly what I was craving. So good! I forgot to ask them not to brown the cheese, but luckily it was perfect.

Went for the first time and will definitely be going back! Pizza was really good and the staff was super nice.

I dont care how many times I have ordered from this place. They always seem to burn the $h! + out of my food. No joke. No matter what I order. For them to charge what they do for food and i can only eat half of it.

I'm done. I cant eat here again.

Our large pizza was smashed so all the chicken and cheese was stuck to the lid. My gluten-free was topped with cheddar for some reason and overcooked to card board. The lady who took the order on the phone seemed annoyed And the delivery driver drove through my yard ‍️

Will stick to the Lewisburg location. Brookville is very disappointing.