Selah Restaurant, Struthers OH

The Tuscan chicken was raw in the middle an had no taste an the salad was very very dry an the cakes had no flavor the chocolate cake was pretty but No flavor an the Banana Split cake was flavor less also as much money as the people paid for this event the food should've been way better!

The food was good but the baked gods are great. Customer service was terrible the waitresses two specific ones were not friendly at all. If you have a large party the don't really suit you together you are to far apart for conversation with the rest of your party.

Saturday before mother's day. I went with my son for this special occasion. I can tell you was worthy every minute. From the appetizers to deserts, excellent experience. We had a great server, Austin, everything was outstanding. The place used to be a bank, not sure how old. Higlhy recommended, Will be back for sure.

What a cozy place. I went to a wedding reception here and it felt like I was in Little Italy in a big city. Such a cool place and atmosphere. The food was fantastic and what a perfect day!

This place is so nice. The servers are always super polite and helpful. The food is delicious every time I go. And not to mention the vibe and aesthetic of the place is immaculate. Its such a cute place to relax and talk with friends over food and drinks.

From the style to the atmosphere, the food, and it's presentation. There are few if any places around that can match selah, if at all. Combining a uniqueness that few see value in, i can hardly remember enjoying myself as much as i have here. My strong recommendation, is the salmon with citrus sauce.

Great little spot. Menu prices are more than generous and so are the portions. Quality of food was outstanding. Props to the Chef. I just happen to stop in because I was in town for work for a day. If I lived in the area this would be my spot. This place rocks. Oh and the place has a theater attached to the restaurant. How cool is that? Staff was very friendly and helpful. I had no clue where I was at.

Very nice restaurant in what used to be a bank. The vault and teller windows are Incorporated in the design.

My fiancée and I really enjoyed our meal here. Our waitress was very attentive and authentically friendly, not the "fake nice just for tips" kind.

Anyone visiting the Youngstown area should try this place. I can tell you for sure that we will be back.

I went there with my lovely wife. It was her birthday and she has always wanted to go.
The service was wonderful.
My wife had the sweet sausage ravioli. I had the bourbon beef tips. Both entrées were fantastic.
The ravioli was tender and well filled with a nice delicate flavor.
The bourbon beef tips were very tender and flavorful.
I also ordered all 4 of their cakes to try.
Pistachio was incredibly flavorful.
I believe it was a raspberry one that my wife and our guests enjoyed the most.
French vanilla and banana were a little bland. But still enjoyable.
We will be returning and I will be recommending Selah to everyone I know
I normally do not give long reviews, but I really enjoyed my dinner there. It was quiet enough that you could have a conversation and not have to listen to everyone else's. We had a reservation for 4pm so that could be why it was peaceful there. This is definitely a great place to take your loved one for a special dinner

While visiting my mom in Yoingstown she took us to Selah for coffee and dessert. We absolutely loved it! A nice lady that appeared to be a manager took great care of us and was so friendly and down to earth. First of all, awesome coffee! I had way too much for a late evening, but couldn’t stop drinking it. Our two cakes we all shared were melt-in-your-mouth moist and light. The icing looks rich, but it’s like whipped cream. The building used to be a bank and they’ve kept a lot of the original set-up and built the restaurant around that. Very cool atheistic. I checked out the food menu and it looks very appealing. The next time I’m in town I’ll be sure to eat here. Thanks for a nice relaxing evening.

Showed up with no reservation in a Saturday night, and we were seated at the bar-which has only four or five seats. Had an absolutely delightful experience watching the barmaid work, and an owner working respectfully alongside.
Drinks, dinner and dessert (as well as cappuccino) were delicious.
I would for sure suggest a reservation-we just got lucky tonight-but maybe at the bar! Cause the staff makes the experience!

This restaurant wants to be fine dining, but the service feels more like a 50s diner. It’s as if the staff lacks the training required to make it the establishment it wants to be. The food was just ok. I really wanted to love it, but it was underwhelming.

A great atmosphere. The food was excellent. The staff couldn’t have been any more nice and efficient and also have been to the upstairs where the main chef cooks for you and explains how to make it. Look fun.

Beautiful local spot. We had pasta and wine. This is a beautiful restaurant. Romantic, perfect setting for a date or family gathering. We loved it ️ Friendly staff and knowledgeable of menu items. What more can you ask for? Perfect.

Honestly, not much I can say other than, try it! You won't be sorry! I don't know how they do it! Always a delight and the food, service, and atmosphere is just all delightful to the soul! Homemade pasta, breads, and cakes made in house every day! Wednesday is gnocchi day with different kinds of gnocchi to choose from and dinner is so popular, you probably should make reservations before you go! You won't be disappointed with their music and shows too. Def follow them on social media!

We were there last week for the live performance upstairs of “ Spoon River Anthology“
Downstairs, we only had drinks and appetizers, served by Tish, which by the way, was a very good server and an especially nice person, that gave exceptionally fast service.
It was our first time there, and it was a very good experience made that way, by Tish!
We certainly will be back, for dinners!

Such an awesome location with a really cool interior. This place was originally a bank and the vault is a private table for larger parties and looks super cool. Still has the old teller counter and windows inside. Combine that with some fantastic decorating and you have one of the more interesting dining experiences in the area.

Sadly, this is where the excitement ends. I met here with family at about 3: 00 and we were the only table in the restaurant for most of the meal. You can tell they make their own dough and can smell the yeast when you walk in. So I was expecting some pretty exceptional food. I always like to guage a new place that serves Italian by simply ordering their spaghetti and meatballs. And after the feel and smell of the place, I was beyond disappointed. The pasta was cooked just about perfect. But the sauce was fairly bland and I have heated sauce from a jar at home with more flavor. The meatballs were also quite bland with not even a hint of garlic. They are either using frozen meatballs or need to seriously work on the recipe. Also was never served bread even just a slice on the side with pasta. I cannot think of anywhere I have ever ordered pasta and never was served any bread or roll or anything. The meal came with no bread, no salad or other starter, and was $12+.

The server was only kinda friendly and didn't really seem like she wanted to be there. Perhaps she was just having a bad day. She bizarrely requested me to turn over my unused silverware when she took my plate and was just generally awkward how she went about certain things. And this place had HER training a new server. While our server wasn't terrible or rude, she also was not very friendly or welcoming and often made the dining experience awkward.

I would recommend anyone pop in to check this place out at least once just because it is so cool inside. And while my spaghetti with meatballs was a bit overpriced and underwhelming, my grandfather said the soup was fantastic.

My takeaway: It is worth seeing once and grabbing a bowl of soup. But I wouldn't recommend the lunch menu and I probably will not go back.

Loved it here! Atmosphere, food, service all a 10/10. I got the chicken francaise and it was delicious. Loved the bread and salad too. I am already looking forward to my next visit.