Sugarcreek Restaurant, Sheffield OH

Really great breakfast selection and buffet! Great an timely service. I had the ham, pineapple, and cheese omelet. Very good. My friend had the pecan, bannana pancakes. So good!

During our stint with covid we were delighted to find that Sugarcreek was on our Grubhub list of restaurants to order from. BIG MISTAKE! Not only did they leave off our soup, rolls and vegetables but they also completely omitted my grandsons corndogs and made a substitution with out our permission or input. The manager was rude and completely blamed grubhub for the mistakes and pretty much told us we were SOL. Congrats you lost a lifelong customer. Never again.

Never once had a bad experience here! We come every weekend for the breakfast buffet, the food is delicious and the staff is always friendly!

The breakfast buffet was so good. Food was Hot & Fresh. The attendant was filling up constantly. We had a Great Waitress she is always friendly.

LOVE this place for brunch! Buffet was always fresh and lots of the usual choices. Quality and price were perfect. Plenty of parking close to door. We're looking forward to dinner someday soon.
Recommended.

Boring staff. One waitress that seemed rushed to get us out before 3pm. First visit from Pa. I don't think I'd go back. Food was good though. Service not so much.

We went for Buffett breakfast they have this small buffet as long as you want scrambled eggs it's fine we seen our waitress 1 and I had to get her to stop for more coffee I won't be going back here.

Food was delicious! It was a Sunday buffet it was fresh and hot I recommend this place for your family. Staff was friendly and nice

Went for breakfast with my Mom. I had strawberry caramel nut French toast. I thought it was quite good. Mom ordered a veggie omelette, said it was ok. Service was fine, no issues at all. Restaurant is located in the corner of a shopping plaza hidden by several fast food places which are closer to the highway.

Its been over 2 years since i visited this place last. Sugar creek had always been my favortie resturant, i always went there for my make-up birthday dinner and always orsere the country fried steak with country gravy. Side of fries and extra gravy to dip in. The last visit i took there was HORRIBLE the menu had completely changed and no item on the menu had been safe from this change. Uncluding the famous dinner rolls that are now cheaped out dollar store bought rolls. My family had been going for 5 generations and this tradition stopped before Covid-19 even began. So i emplore anyone not to go there until they change their menu back to what it was and re-open for the dinner schedule.

I’ve been going here since I was a baby. Sugarcreek will go down in history as my favorite restaurant ever. The servers are so attentive, the owner is kind and the food is superb

I was seated and nothing was said to me by the host. After I was seated I waited about 5 mins before the server even came over to speak.the only thing that was good was the omelet.

I went to The Sugar creek Restaurant for the first time. It is amazing! The food is delicious, the service is great, and the style is very great! I really recommend this to anyone who finds a restaurant with a long wait. This place barely even has a wait! Great place!

Amazing service. Never a long wait either. We went to the Sugarcreek Restaurant today and all of our food was out in 15-20 minutes. There is another breakfast place here called Cracker Barrel, but always has a long wait, while the Sugarcreek restaurant has a short one probably because of the fact that it is in an old plaza with many old stores. Hard to find with maps, but it’s in the corner of a plaza behind aldi. Overall great restaurant.

We had a party of 18 and they treated us so well our only complaint is that they were definitely under staffed, and we felt so bad for the wait staff, but they were awesome!

First time eating out in a year! The food was excellent and reasonably priced The service outstanding. I was charged the wrong price for one item, the manager corrected it cheerfully I love this place. I highly recommended this restaurant

Really enjoy the food and the staff. Its got a old feel to it but its a hidden jem for sure. Our favorite part is the little buffet they do on Saturday and Sundays from 8am till 2pm

It was very good food that is reasonably priced. The service was slow but that is proably because they were understaffed. It is very hard now to get and keep staff. The ones that.were there tried their best