Teresa's Pizza-Sagamore Hills, Northfield OH

Ordered a sheet of pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni 2 orders of cheesey bread sticks with marinara sauce. What I got was 2 large pizzas and told I needed to give them 24 hr in advance for the sheet which was never said before hand. The cheese bread ended up being half of garlic toast with cheese on it and no marinara sauce. Was supposed to be cheesey bread sticks no garlic mentioned. Don't recommend this place at all.ok pizza is so damn good gotta up it jus for that. Forgot my marinara and menu though.and bread sticks are still sad af.

Called after looking at their online menu, half the stuff we asked for they didnt have, and havent had in a long time.then we asked if they can do a sheet pizza, guy gladly says oh yea we can do a sheet.delivery driver gets here and tells us we're supposed to give them 24 hours in advance.so we got 2 "xlarge" pizzas cut into 32 pieces. Our "cheesy breadsticks" with marinara were 4 pieces of garlic bread with cheese melted on them and no marinara sauce.receipt had no prices on it except the total due amount.extremely bad first impression for me.probably never ordering from there again.

Ordered a large pep pizza Saturday night. Their delivery driver pulled up blasting music in my neighborhood at 9pm. Pizza had long blonde hair in it, matched the delivery drivers hair. Undercooked, doughy in the middle. Horrible.

Love their large pepperoni pizza, eat it fresh and hot or as leftovers either way it doesn’t disappoint!

First time trying Teresa's, won't be the last. Picked up a Large with sausage and pepperoni. I must admit, when I opened the box I was underwhelmed - the toppings were under the cheese and the pizza didn't look very "large. " But it was delicious, and they definitely didn't skimp on anything - plenty of toppings and sauce, and cheese that most places would charge extra for. Good texture and flavor to the crust. I almost took off one star because the price seemed high, but the price is actually in line with what other one-off shops and local chains charge. You can pay much less if you get a promo from a national chain, but but that level of quality just isn't the same. I can't justify spending this much all the time but Teresa's will be a nice treat now and then when I want "good" pizza and not just something quick and cheap. Absolutely worth a try.