The Original Josie's Pizza, Columbus OH

We were back from Tennessee and of course we came back to josie's pizza. We got our Stromboli and meatball sub. Yummy as usual. Coming back again for our pizza bef6we head on back to Tennessee. We will miss this place most of all. Keep making the best pizza on earth. Your Tennessee friend's.

I placed an order on Wednesday for an Italian sub, perfection, I loved it. Fast forward to today and I wanted pizza first thing that came to mind was Josies, so I call and the lady who answered remembered who I was and the day I ordered! In this day and age, where customers are just a dollar sign, it felt great be genuinely acknowledged. I will be a regular because she made me feel like I already was! Great food great vibe great people! I will definitely be returning and will definitely recommend them to anyone who wants a pizza, sub, or wings, and to anyone who wants that nostalgic, "come back again y'all hear? ! " Feeling. Kudos You guys kudos.

The pizza was very much MID! It did not look like the pizza posted on the website. I ordered a pepperoni pizza. There were NO pepperoni on the pizza. The pepperoni was placed on the sauce and then topped with cheese to hide the fact that there were NO pepperoni on the pizza. Grocery store pizza is better than this place.

I ordered Josie’s while on a trip because of the reviews. I ordered a large pepperoni well done. My favorite part, the dough. Super fresh and was great tasting. The sauce was okay. The price was a little steep for the pizza I ordered. The area surrounding the building was a little suspicious. When I pulled up, I thought this cannot be the right building however, it was. The parking lot was weird and the entrance that you had to go when you had to park further because there was only handicap parking right by the doors. I would try again but wouldn’t go out if my way to stop here.

Been eating this pizza since a little girl. Will always hv a special place in my heart! Hands down thee best pizza in the Midwest

Josie’s is easily one of the best pizzas in Columbus and a true to form Columbus style pizza. I always go for the classic Pepperoni, but their specialties are great too. They’ve got great subs and apps as well! Definitely get yourself some Josie’s if you’ve not already!

The pizza is wonderful.we have never had a bad pizza from josie's. We love the old fashioned pepperoni and the ability to have a very tasty burger delivered for those times we are wanting something other than pizza delivered
Google requested I update my review.
New location, just a few doors down from the old location and same old great taste.
Service is still perfect. They mentioned having some new updates to the location coming soon.

Very good pizza. Will try double pepperoni and well done next time. Nice drivers. They don't make tipping very easy, though, I'll say that.

I've always had excellent service and have yet to have any issues with my order. I have recommended Josies to several people and they now order from them on a regular basis. All the employees are always friendly even when they are very busy they all hold their composure. The only thing I have to say in a negative way is they are only open until 10pm. Josies Pizza is my favorite pizza place. They also offer dinners, salads, and fried foods with reasonable prices that everyone can afford

It is very good pizza. Crust was light and nice. Hadn't been here for years.nicer location. Sports ready.

The pizza was delicious, but the crust was outstanding! I'm not sure I can describe it properly. It was crisp, like buttery crust, and then immediately tender. I don't know how they do that on a thin crust pizza... But they do. I worked at Mount Carmel West for 37 years, so I had Josie's a lot and it was so good then, but, honestly, I feel it's even better now! I love the spot they are in, just down the street from the previous location. There is lots of room for dine in. The staff was so friendly and welcoming!

I love their pizza it's better than regular fast food pizza places. And they have never messed up on any of my orders. I normally get the same delivery driver to he's very respectful.

Their original pepperoni pizza is mouth watering. Highly recommend this staple to the community. Fast and accurate service