Gem Set Love (formerly Gilt)

This shop has it all - an excellent selection of vintage jewels, knowledgeable staff, and friendly customer service!
My partner and I stopped in here to look at their engagement rings and I fell in love with an engagement ring/wedding band set.
A few weeks later, my partner proposed with that set. It needed to be resized, and gem set love was able to resize both rings in only 3 days. Wow, I’m so thrilled to wear and admire this vintage beauty everyday! As someone who loves all things vintage and values sustainability, this store and my ring checks all my boxes!

Paula is a great jeweler. I inherited some pieces that weren’t my style and I brought them to her at Gem Set Love and got back 3 pieces I love. I wear them everyday. I had no clue how to proceed and she patiently listened to my meanderings about simplistic and classic styles and came up with 3 new settings that were perfect. I love perusing their vintage styles as well and will invest in some more pieces in the near future!

Beautiful shop with high quality vintage pieces. I have 2 rings from here and absolutely love them.

I bought a gorgeous strand of vintage pearls from Gem Set Love, online. I just love them! I ended up having an issue with the clasp, probably because of the age of the strand of pearls. Anyway, I reached out to Paula and she got back to me right away. She immediately had me return the pearls (at no cost to me) to repair the clasp. Once I got the strand back it started acting up again. Once again, I reached out to Paula to let her know. She immediately responded to me and had me return the pearls again (again at no cost to me). She went above and beyond by finding a new (and equally beautiful) vintage clasp for my pearls. Once she found it and fixed the strand she returned them to me. I was so pleased to have them back. The new clasp is both beautiful and very durable so everything worked out great! Paula was a delight to work with. She really cares about her product and her customers. That was evident to me in all my dealings with her. I wish the entire world would operate their businesses the way Paula does. The world would be a much happier and easier place!

Took my best friend engagement ring shopping here a few years ago after having a very negative experience elsewhere and they were so nice. When it came time to find a wedding band for my fiancé it was a no brainer to come here, engaging and friendly they helped us find a beautiful vintage band that they engraved in house for us.

Wonderful service. Happy we waited for a private appointment. Beautiful selection of vintage rings. Thank you!

The most beautiful unique jewelry. Great location as well.