Alfees Pizza, Erie PA

Wings over cooked, wrong type sent. Terrible pizza flavor. Sauce was sour. I will never order here again. Save yourself money and go fast food before this place.

We were spending a weekend at Splash Lagoon, saw the coupons in the lobby. Told the hotel clerk that we do not like to eat at chains, that we like to support local and wanted somewhere to sit down and eat. She recommended Alfees as well, so we went for dine in. Definately just a pizza joint, everyone was very friendly, service was fast, and food was good! We ordered wings, pizza, cheese sticks and pizza logs. No issues with the food or the service!

I ORDERED THERE FOR YEARS BUT NOT ANYMORE FOR PIZZA, WINGS, THEY ARE USUALLY BURNT, DRIED OUT, SO IS PIZZA, HIGHWAY ROBBERY!

So I used to love this place but thay went down hill the last 3 time I ordered it wasn't grate and the pizza never comes wen thay say. Today thay sayed 45 mins it took almost 2 hrs the pizza was burt and the cheese sticks were so over cooked thay were hard as a rock till thay get back to the way thay used to run. The only good part was the the driver was nice and sayed sorry

Great food and service. Parking is tight but I was in and out within 5 minutes. Highly recommend Alfees Pizza.

First time visit: 5/28/2023
Ordered pizza and Greek Fries.
Best pizza I have ever eaten. I loved the flavor and crust.
The fries were fabulous, too.

We will definitely return.

First time customer. Our pizza was one of the best I've ever had, the fries were aweseeome too. We will definitely be repeat customers.

Wings were mostly bones and not much meat. They also have a significant price difference between what it shows online versus what they actually charge and they claim they know about it but it has not been updated.

Very disappointed with the quality of food. No way we are going back to this place.

The food came quick and that was a good thing but my pizza was scorched tasting and burned on the bottom, please fix this cause this takes away from the otherwise great tasting pizza. Ps btw sombody said if you roll the dough in cornmeal instead of flour it won’t burn, I don’t know just a thought

I received my wings but it was the wrong ones for the second time that I delivered to my job. I tried to call back the driver, but no answer. I text him about it. Hopefully I get reimbursed or my wings. Also there wasn’t any ranch which I know it comes with. But the wings were spicy and taste like ranch wings not butter garlic Parmesan which I get every time so I know what they taste and look like. I didn’t complain about it the first time, but the second time is a problem. Please fix this issue thank you.

We used to order here all the time, but in the last 6yrs. Or so our orders are always messed up some how or other!

If you're looking for a big name pizza, stick to the chains. But if you want pizza that tastes like it's homemade this is the place to call.

I went to visit my hometown and of course needed to have a home town favorite, pizza balls, no salt.sorry no pictures but they are delicious

This was an awful experience. We placed the order at 4: 30 for a 9pm delivery. The pizza didn’t get delivered until 9: 35pm. We had hungry kids expecting pepperoni pizza. They gave us a mushroom, onion and ham pizza. Gave us the wrong wings and overcharged me. When I called politely to complain the person answering the phone got nasty saying that he couldn’t replace the pizza, in addition to when I said I shouldn’t have been overcharged, he told me that I probably signed the wrong receipt. Not to mention, the pizza that we did get was trash.

We were on a family trip @ Splash Lagoon and Alfee's pizzia fliers were everywhere in the Lobby. We ordered a few pizzas and not one person out of 14 pizza lovers liked the pizza. After one bite we all tossed it in the garbage. And the fact that some of the teenage boys will eat just about anything and not picky at all says alot!

Ordered wings and pizza combo. Wings were overcooked and hard to eat. The pizza was burnt on the bottom. Mushrooms looked like they were from a can or jar.