Annie Bailey's Irish Public House, Lancaster PA

Came here at 7 and had to wait for a table. Plenty of room at the bar at that point, left around 9 and the bar was packed full but tables were emptier. Service at both the bar and table were phenomenal. These cocktails were among the best I've had in Lancaster. Everything was truly delicious and I would absolutely return.

We were just here recently for brunch after a wedding. The food was great. The cheesesteak rolls & the brussel sprouts were our favorite. But the Bloody Mary's there take the cake. If you love spicy, they are 10/10

Excellent food and service! First time here and really enjoyed it! We were warmly welcomed and couldn’t get over the great taste of food… so delicious! Highly recommend! Thank you for a great experience on our getaway! Kim was very attentive and made us feel relaxed. Very impressed.

Price - 3/5
Quality - 4/5
Atmosphere - 4.5/5

Total - 11.5/15

Great place for a date or drink. Not cheap, but it’s what you’d expect for an uppity inner city pub.

Good selection of drinks and I love the decor/atmosphere. Staff is friendly and even hop into the conversation which I always appreciate a friendly staff!

This restaurant was just okay. The food was very slow in coming out. It took 45 minutes to get our appetizers and a full hour for our entrees. I should note that the restaurant was slightly more than half full. So, it wasn't like they were slammed. The waitress was okay, but drinks not being refilled while waiting so long for food was annoying.

The food itself was mixed. The brussel sprout appetizer was fantastic. My burger was good and the mashed potatoes I got with it were great. But the others in my party thought their meals (shepherds pie and pulled pork cuban) were nothing special.

I should note that they did offer a few gluten free options and seemed knowledgeable about cross contamination, so that was appreciated.

It wasn't a bad experience, but for the money it wasn't worth it.

Do not send anybody from your bridal party or wedding guests here. The staff was EXTREMELY rude to myself (the bride and my Groom) after just getting married. We are all in our 30’s and were not any bit rowdy. They refused all of us at the door (10 of us). Would not even allow the bride or groom to enter since we were coming from a wedding due to “town policy. ” Not sure how these guys make money as weddings are what bring people into town. Send your bridal party to Quipps for a great experience and good service. Thanks again for being a complete buzz kill right after my wedding.

Went there for the Irish music. Receptionist said the musicians cancelled. Really disappointed!

Great place.inside and outside seating. Food was delicious, large portions Nice drink menu.

Great pub food in a pub-like atmosphere. Shepherds pie (regular and vegan) were really good as was the reuben. Waitress was really nice and helpful

Had a wonderful time thanks to our waiter, Max! He did an amazing job and really helped guide us through the menu for our first time. Thanks, Max!

I ordered the petite steak medium well & it was overcooked & dry but the potatoes were delicious & the service was really slow.

As all reviews said the Shepherd's Pie is amazing. They have menu on cube that scan to look on phone and I know, I'm old and after working all day looking at screen I don't want to be on phone any longer. They gave us paper menus without making us feel bad which is not always the case and I appreciate the understanding. Server was really attentive and friendly. Food runner deserves an award, he was RUNNING. Nice, clean place. Would visit again.

I came in for brunch and had the worst experience my server Brendan was a disaster he was forgetting everything and messing up the orders, he was nodding off at the table and seemed out of it. I was very disappointed in the service and won’t ever come back. I highly recommend asking for a new server if he is taking care of you.

The Amish rub wings were soo good crispy yet juicy and flavorful! Our waitress was kind and quick!

Great central PA vibe. It's not easy to find this kind of place where we live in LA. It's a gem and shouldn't be taken for granted.

Let's start at when we walked in. The dinning room isn't very clean looking. Dusty, dirty so we sat on the deck. Lillie was ok. She wasn't very personable. The food is so good tho. The pot pie, steak and that carrot cake! So good whatever is in the middle is delightful. Would eat a bowl of that alone!

Had a great time with my boyfriend, the atmosphere was so cool and something I’ve never experienced before. It is up there in price but we went all out.