Anthony's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Malvern PA

We just came back from this restaurant with an horrible dine in experience. We came to this restaurant for a dinner. Arrived there at 8PM ESt and all went initially. We were given a table and the waitress came to the table after few minutes to take the order for drinks and appetizers. After few minutes she came back asking for the order for main course where we asked for few more minutes. Then we placed the main course order, which was nothing but a vegetarian pizza. After 15 mins the waitress came to let us know the Pizza is getting ready and should be there any time. From here, the waitress disappeared while we waited for the food.time passed, we asked other waiters with not much movement, finally our waitress came and trying to inquire whether the food is there or not. By this almost 30 mins passed. She went inside to inquire about and came back to let us know that our order has been served to some other table and the chef is preparing another pizza which may take another 5 to 10 mins and she also asked if that can be served or packed for delivery, we asked her to serve it on the table.then the wait game again continued for 15 more mins and she came back to tell us similar stories like our food was given to a "take away" order. This was frustrating by now, she again repeated the same thing, whether we can wait or she can pack the order which will take another 15 mins. By now it is really frustrating to wait more time, I asked them to cancel the order and it seems she was pretty happy with our response. Immediately she came back with the check to pay and leave.

From this kind of experience, where we neither got the food nor got any good response from the waiter (she just mentioned, it is not under her control, not sue why she is allowed to attend a table if she can not manage it) or restaurant staff, my suggestion, please do not plan for a pleasant dinner if you are going with your family to spend some time there, it might ruin your plan.

My guess- They also have a take away counter where they just deliver and they don't have proper management to manage dine in and take away orders, it's a mess.

Best mom and pop Italian in the area. All the food is fantastic and the pizza is so good, we get it as an app for the table. Highly recommend.

I have been coming here for years with the family. The recent renovation looks amazing and now they can serve wine or beer or some speciality cocktails. They have changed a lot over the years but always do a great job. The food was amazing and filling as always.

Always yummy food. Pasta, pizza and sandwiches are all tasty. Chicken is super efficient, even for large parties. Portions are generous, so even large appetites are satisfied.

The food was great but moreover, the coffee was amazing. I should’ve asked what brand of coffee they have.

Pizza was good but service was not. Servers were rushing to close restaurant and one lady was very rude to us. Also servers started cleaning up everything while we were still at the table within still 1h to close restaurant. Not coming back here and not recommending to anyone.

Pizaa was good and real old authentic pizza in Malvern downtown! Meat lovers and veg plain cheese pizza are good.

Got take-out, food was horrible, salads weren't fresh. Most of the 56 bucks went in the trash. $56 was for 2 adult entries and a child's pasta. My grandkids said it sucked.

I had really high hopes for Anthony’s. We ordered a pizza but they had put so much balsamic glaze on the pizza that made the pizza so wet and soggy. Literally the only thing you could taste was the balsamic and the crust was wet. We had to throw out the entire pizza. Very disappointed.

Even though it's renovated, the space is super noisy. Too many hard surfaces. Salads are good but 7.25$ for a piece of chicken added to an entree salad makes it $20. I know food prices have gone up but that's crazy.

Very crowded for 5: 30, Saturday. The wait, they don't accept reservations, was absolutely worth it. I had the chicken piccata, and it was one of the best I've ever enjoyed. The lemony sauce was creamy and flavorful. Plenty of lovely little capers for every bite. The chicken was tender, lightly browned and just perfect. Accompanying the very generous portion of my main entree was another huge portion of spaghetti in marinara. Delicious. I brought most of it home for Sunday leftovers. I would have like a bit more zing in the marinara sauce but it wasn't b look and. It could have used more garlic, in my opinion. Both dishes were delicious. For dessert my friend and I shared a slice of pumpkin cheesecake which was fresh and creamy. Pumpkiny yet still cheesecake. Delicious. The pricing was reasonable especially for the portion size. The restaurant evidently acquired a liquor license and now sp ki gets a bar just inside the entrance. Handy place to have since there were enty of people waiting for a table. Nice family friendly restaurant with a wonderful, warm staff that are not affected or smug.which you frequently come across dining in the main line. I highly recommend this restaurant for a great Italian meal and a lovely evening out for dinner. My dining companions both loved their meals as well.: shrimp scampi and chicken marsala. I didn't try the shrimp scampi but sampled a bite of the chicken marsala and it too was perfection. Tge marsala sauce was bursting with flavor and the mushrooms were cooked to perfection. The chicken was cooked to the same perfection as my piccata. Hats off to the talent in the kitchen for a beautiful meal that I'm sure more than just our group enjoyed Saturday evening. We'll be back and looking forward to it.

Anthony’s is one of our favorite places to go when we are craving great italian or pizza! The recently renovated interior is beautiful and it just has a real cozy, inviting feel and also has a bar now which is great! There is a wide selection of wines and beers to enjoy. The staff is always wonderful as well!

We recently had ordered catering from Anthony’s as well for my sons birthday party and the food was absolutely delicious. Everyone raved about it, especially the chicken piccata and baked ziti! The amount you get for the price is great. We highly recommend Anthony’s!

Very disappointed in the gummy, undercooked spaghetti with shrimp scampi. They claim spaghetti is homemade but it sure didn't taste so. Some shrimp on the top of dish were fresh and the others were a different quality. I suggest sticking to pizza when going here! Waitress was snippy and of no help in rectifying this dish.

The pizza is good. Prices are expensive for what you get though; a kids baked penne is $16 (!).

Fantastic food, they are under construction in the front 1/4 of the dine in area. Wait was about 5 min, staff could not have been nicer.

Loved Anthony's, the food was fantastic and everyone was really nice. Definitely cant wait to come back!

Went on a Saturday night around 5: 30 pm, got in before the rush. Food and service was excellent! House made ravioli and Lasagna were great, antipasto is the real deal. People know this place so it fills up, go early or wait in line, it's worth it.

Went to the restaurant area once, was very good service and delicious food. Always get take out, delicious pizza and gluten friendly options!

We had an excellent authentic Italian dinner last nite at Anthony’s Italian Restaurant in Malvern, the food was great, the ambiance was excellent and the service and our waitress was even better! Only problem is that I wish it was closer to our home! Salute!

My wife and I stopped in on a Saturday around 6: 15 PM. The place was packed and understandably so. The food was great tasting and plentiful. The service was prompt however I would recommend visiting when it's less busy just a noise preference on my part