Benny's Italian Eatery, Boiling Springs PA

I went on vacation and got pizza, ate it, then spent the rest of vacation looking forward to eating at Benny again. The best pizza around. Would recommend!

Great food at a reasonable price. The number one thing that that I like is consistency of the food from here. It is always very much the same.

This is the downfall of many of the other restaurants around here. You roll the dice and hope for the best often to be disappointed. Tonight is one of those nights for me. I ordered from another restaurant that is much closer. The food was not so good. I will drive a little further from now on and get my food from Benny’s.

First time there. Close to work and my crew loved it… next time I’ll get two and start sampling Subs

Benny's is a small Pizza joint just down the road from the Children's Lake and across from all the South Middleton schools. I'm usually ordering 5 to 8 pizzas at a time for larger groups and these guys always have them ready for me in about 30 minutes. They are always friendly and greet me when I arrive. They are appreciative of the business and help carry the food out to my vehicle. I choose them over the competition down the road every time.

Had a cheese steak hoagie. The best. I assume the rolls are made in house, cuz they hold up and are not all thick and doughy.

Great spot for lunch!

I walked in 30 minutes before closing on a random Friday evening. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. The guys behind the counter were friendly and welcoming.

We try to order Benny's takeout several times each month. There isn't a bad thing on the menu, I've tried it all. My favorite is the Philly cheesesteak pizza. The crust is perfect, thin foldable slices. The tomatoe sauce is heavenly. Oh and my daughter can't eat enough of their chicken Parm.