Betsy's Ice Cream, Mt Lebanon PA

These folks really know what they’re doing. Great flavors and service! Get a cup so you can indulge in the unlimited toppings bar.

When entering the front door I was afraid to get a splinter …… it looks like the door hasn’t been painted since 1973! The store had a musty odor.
When looking in the back the floors look like they haven’t been mopped for years!
The trash flip lids were sticky from old ice cream smears!
Now the staff.we asked if they had anything with coconut and neither one of the two knew they had it. We had to point out to them that they had 2 varieties.
Will not be returning!

The Lemon Rose Water was light & refreshing. The Young Men maning the counter were kind, honest & patient with Me & My Family! Proper Young Guys! Nostalgic atomsphere. Ice Cream was pretty good, choices for everyone. Nice little gem to try after you've had a delicious meal at one of the many restaurants on Washington Rd.

I used to like this place a lot better but the last few times it has just been kind of meh. I asked for an ice cream sandwich but they were out of cookies. Instead, I ordered a regular ice cream. I received a super small serving of ice cream and there were no signs of moose in my moose tracks ice cream. No moose peanut butter cups or moose peanut butter cup crumbles. No moose fudge. Just a few small flakes of something that may or may not have been moose related but didn't have any flavor.

For anyone dairy free or looking for a healthier alternative to ice cream… GET THE BANANA WHIP! It’s just frozen bananas that they run through a magical machine that make it just like a soft serve. Get it with a bit of hot fudge and it is perfect! Never stop selling it!